A formal drawing for a machine part includes datum features that are used to construct a datum reference frame (drf) for the part. A feature Control frame (fcf) for each datum feature that is intended to eliminate roll about a fixed primary axis of the drf includes a material location modifier which specifies whether the orientation or the location of the feature should be used to eliminate roll. The material location modifiers enable specification of Independent of material location (IML), at Basic material location (BML), at Maximum material location (MML) and at Least material location (LML), eliminate all ambiguity in the formal drawing, and enable a drf to be constructed automatically using a computer. The material location modifiers further eliminate any possibility of misinterpretation of the formal drawing during all stages of manufacture and inspection of the part. A computer program implementing a method of the invention includes instructions for constructing a drf in response to the dimensions, tolerances, FRC datum feature sequence and material location modifiers using a set of rules and specific drf construction tools. The tools include ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, SET ORIGIN, TRANSLATE and ROTATE, and are applied in order to sequentially eliminate pitch, yaw, roll, and translation from the drf.
|
48. A data storage medium which stores a computer program for constructing a datum reference frame (drf) for an object in response to a specification of datum features of the object including a sequence in which the datum features are to be processed, and a material location modifier for a datum feature which is intended to eliminate roll in the drf, the material location modifier designating whether said datum feature should be used to eliminate roll using said datum feature's orientation or location.
29. A method of constructing a feature Control frame (fcf) for controlling the geometry of a feature of an object using a computer, comprising the steps of:
(a) providing the computer with a program for constructing an fcf in response to a specification of a dimension, a tolerance, and a material location modifier for a datum feature, the fcf including a material location modifier symbol corresponding to the material location modifier; (b) inputting a specification into the computer; and (c) executing the program.
1. A method of constructing a datum reference frame (drf) for an object using a computer, comprising the steps of:
(a) providing the computer with a program for constructing a drf in response to a specification of datum features of the object including a sequence in which the datum features are to be processed, and a material location modifier for a datum feature which is intended to eliminate roll in the drf, the material location modifier designating whether said datum feature should be used to eliminate roll using said datum feature's orientation or location; (b) inputting a specification into the computer; and (c) executing the program.
38. An apparatus which constructs a datum reference frame (drf) for an object, comprising:
memory means for storing a program including instructions for constructing a drf in response to a specification of datum features of the object including a sequence in which the datum features are to be processed, and a material location modifier for a datum feature which is intended to eliminate roll in the drf, the material location modifier designating whether said datum feature should be used to eliminate roll using said datum feature's orientation or location; input means for inputting a specification; and processing means for executing the program.
23. A method for specifying and constructing an unambiguous datum reference frame (drf) for an object, comprising the steps of:
(a) providing a specification of datum features of the object including a sequence in which the datum features are to be processed, and a material location modifier for a datum feature which is intended to eliminate roll in the drf, the material location modifier designating whether said datum feature should be used to eliminate roll using said datum feature's orientation or location; and (b) constructing the drf by processing the specification using a procedure which includes implementation of the material location modifier.
47. A computer aided design (CAD) system which constructs a datum reference frame (drf) for an object, comprising:
memory means for storing a program including instructions for constructing a drf in response to a specification of datum features of the object including a sequence in which the datum features are to be processed, and a material location modifier for a datum feature which is intended to eliminate roll in the drf, the material location modifier designating whether said datum feature should be used to eliminate roll using said datum feature's orientation or location; input means for inputting a specification; and processing means for executing the program.
2. A method as in
3. A method as in
step (a) comprises providing the program to construct the drf in response to the specification by using datum feature simulators whose locations are controlled by the material location modifier; and the datum feature simulators are inverses of corresponding datum features.
4. A method as in
5. A method as in
6. A method as in
7. A method as in
if said datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the material location modifier can be at Basic material location (BML); and if said datum feature does not have size, the material location modifier can be at Maximum material location (MML) or at Least material location (LML).
8. A method as in
9. A method as in
if said datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, a default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); and if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the default material location modifier is Independent of material location (IML).
10. A method as in
if said datum feature has size and straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the material location modifier can be at BML; and if said datum feature does not have size, the material location modifier can be at Maximum material location (MML) or at Least material location (LML).
11. A method as in
12. A method as in
if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and does not have size, a default material location modifier is at Maximum material location (MML); if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and has size, the default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); and if said datum feature has size, or does not have size and does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML).
13. A method as in
14. A method as in
15. A method as in
16. A method as in
17. A method as in
18. A method as in
19. A method as in
20. A method as in
step (a) comprises providing the program to construct the drf in response to the specification by using datum feature simulators whose locations are controlled by the material location modifier; the datum feature simulators are inverses of corresponding datum features; and step (a) comprises providing the program to construct the drf in response to the specification in accordance with the following rules: RULE OF material ORIENTATION--the orientations of datum feature simulators are fixed relative to one another at the basic angles of their corresponding datum features; RULES OF material location--(i) datum feature simulators which do not serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of the drf are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums; (ii) datum feature simulators representing datum targets are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums, whether or not they serve to eliminate roll; (iii) the manner in which datum feature simulators serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of a drf is determined by explicit material location Modifiers or by material location modifier defaults; RULE OF material CONDITION--datum feature simulators representing datum features with size are fixed at Virtual material Condition (VMC) if accompanied by Maximum material Condition (MMC) or Least material Condition (LMC) modifiers, and will otherwise expand or contract to consume all space inside or outside respective datum features; FIRST RULE OF PRECEDENCE--datum features listed in a feature Control frame (fcf) will be used in the order in which they appear; SECOND RULE OF PRECEDENCE--ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, and SET ORIGIN tools will be applied in order; the program will attempt to use each datum feature first to eliminate pitch and yaw, then to eliminate roll, and then to eliminate the three degrees of translational freedom; RULE OF MAXIMUM UTILIZATION--each datum feature must contribute everything it can and may to eliminating the six degrees of freedom of a drf; RULE OF COMPOSITE feature CONTROL frames--datum features listed in a first tier of a composite feature control frame are empowered to remove both translational and rotational degrees of drf freedom; datum features listed in a second tier and all lower tiers of a composite feature control frame may only remove rotational degrees of freedom; RULE OF NON-OVERRIDE--no datum features may override degrees of freedom eliminated by previous datum features; RULE OF SIMULTANEITY--all features referenced to a same mobile drf must meet their requirements simultaneously unless modified by a notation indicating that they are separate; in the case of separate groups of features referenced to the same mobile drfs defined by second and lower tiers of separate composite feature control frames, the rule of simultaneity applies separately within each group. 21. A method as in
(a1) identifying a next datum feature in the sequence; (a2) determining if pitch and yaw have already been eliminated; (a3) if pitch and yaw have not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature is capable of eliminating pitch and yaw, applying an ORIENT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate pitch and yaw; (a4) determining if roll has been eliminated; (a5) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (a6) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with the material location modifier Independent of material location (IML), applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (a7) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Basic material location (BML), Maximum material location (MML) or Least material location (LML), applying a PIVOT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's location; (a8) determining if all degrees of translational freedom have been eliminated; (a9) if all degrees of translational freedom have not been eliminated, applying a SET ORIGIN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate all permissible and possible degrees of translational freedom; (a10) determining if all degrees of freedom have been eliminated; (a11) if all degrees of freedom have not been eliminated and more datum features exist, repeating steps (al) to (a10), otherwise terminating the method.
22. A method as in
(a1) identifying a next datum feature in the sequence; (a2) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (a3) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Independent of material location (IML), applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; and (a4) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Basic material location (BML), Maximum material location (MML), or Least material location (LML), applying a PIVOT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's location.
24. A method as in
25. A method as in
26. A method as in
if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the default material location modifier is Independent of material location (IML).
27. A method as in
if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and does not have size, a default material location modifier is at Maximum material location (MML); if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and has size, the default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); and if said datum feature has size, or does not have size and does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML).
28. A method as in
30. A method as in
31. A method as in
32. A method as in
33. A method as in
34. A method as in
35. A method as in
36. A method as in
37. A method as in
the set includes a material location modifier which is inappropriate for said datum feature; and the program does not display or enable selection of said material location modifier which is inappropriate for said datum feature.
39. An apparatus as in
40. An apparatus as in
41. An apparatus as in
if said datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, a default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); and if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, a default material location modifier is Independent of material location (IML).
42. An apparatus as in
if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and does not have size, a default material location modifier is at Maximum material location (MML); if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and has size, a default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); if said datum feature has size, or does not have size and does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML).
43. An apparatus as in
44. An apparatus as in
the program constructs the drf in response to the specification by using datum feature simulators whose locations are controlled by the material location modifier; the datum feature simulators are inverses of corresponding datum features; and the program constructs the drf in response to the specification in accordance with the following rules: RULE OF material ORIENTATION--the orientations of datum feature simulators are fixed relative to one another at the basic angles of their corresponding datum features; RULES OF material location--(i) datum feature simulators which do not serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of the drf are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums; (ii) datum feature simulators representing datum targets are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums, whether or not they serve to eliminate roll; (iii) the manner in which datum feature simulators serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of a drf is determined by explicit material location Modifiers or by material location modifier defaults. RULE OF material CONDITION--datum feature simulators representing datum features with size are fixed at Virtual material Condition (VMC) if accompanied by Maximum material Condition (MMC) or Least material Condition (LMC) modifiers, and will otherwise expand or contract to consume all space inside or outside respective datum features; FIRST RULE OF PRECEDENCE--datum features listed in a feature Control frame (fcf) will be used in the order in which they appear; SECOND RULE OF PRECEDENCE--ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, and SET ORIGIN tools will be applied in order; the program will attempt to use each datum feature first to eliminate pitch and yaw, then to eliminate roll, and then to eliminate the three degrees of translational freedom; RULE OF MAXIMUM UTILIZATION--each datum feature must contribute everything it can and may to eliminating the six degrees of freedom of a drf; RULE OF COMPOSITE feature CONTROL frames--datum features listed in a first tier of a composite feature control frame are empowered to remove both translational and rotational degrees of drf freedom; datum features listed in a second tier and all lower tiers of a composite feature control frame may only remove rotational degrees of freedom; RULE OF NON-OVERRIDE--no datum features may override degrees of freedom eliminated by previous datum features; RULE OF SIMULTANEITY--all features referenced to a same mobile drf must meet their requirements simultaneously unless modified by a notation indicating that they are separate; in the case of separate groups of features referenced to the same mobile drfs defined by second and lower tiers of separate composite feature control frames, the rule of simultaneity applies separately within each group. 45. An apparatus as in
(a) identifying a next datum feature in the sequence; (b) determining if pitch and yaw have already been eliminated; (c) if pitch and yaw have not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature is capable of eliminating pitch and yaw, applying an ORIENT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate pitch and yaw; (d) determining if roll has been eliminated; (e) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (f) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with the material location modifier Independent of material location (IML), applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (g) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Basic material location (BML), Maximum material location (MML) or Least material location (LML), applying a PIVOT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's location; (h) determining if all degrees of translational freedom have been eliminated; (i) if all degrees of translational freedom have not been eliminated, applying a SET ORIGIN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate all permissible and possible degrees of translational freedom; (j) determining if all degrees of freedom have been eliminated; (k) if all degrees of freedom have not been eliminated and more datum features exist, repeating steps (a) to (j), otherwise terminating processing.
46. An apparatus as in
(a) identifying a next datum feature in the sequence; (b) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (c) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Independent of material location (IML), applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; and (d) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Basic material location (BML), Maximum material location (MML), or Least material location (LML), applying a PIVOT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's location.
49. A medium as in
50. A medium as in
51. A medium as in
if said datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, a default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the default material location modifier is Independent of material location (IML).
52. A medium as in
if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and does not have size, a default material location modifier is at Maximum material location (MML); if said datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf and has size, the default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML); if said datum feature has size, or does not have size and does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, the default material location modifier is at Basic material location (BML).
53. A medium as in
54. A medium as in
the program constructs the drf in response to the specification by using datum feature simulators whose locations are controlled by the material location modifier; the datum feature simulators are inverses of corresponding datum features; and the program constructs the drf in response to the specification in accordance with the following rules: RULE OF material ORIENTATION--the orientations of datum feature simulators are fixed relative to one another at the basic angles of their corresponding datum features; RULES OF material location--(i) datum feature simulators which do not serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of the drf are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums; (ii) datum feature simulators representing datum targets are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums, whether or not they serve to eliminate roll; (iii) the manner in which datum feature simulators serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of a drf is determined by explicit material location Modifiers or by material location modifier defaults; RULE OF material CONDITION--datum feature simulators representing datum features with size are fixed at Virtual material Condition (VMC) if accompanied by Maximum material Condition (MMC) or Least material Condition (LMC) modifiers, and will otherwise expand or contract to consume all space inside or outside respective datum features; FIRST RULE OF PRECEDENCE--datum features listed in a feature Control frame (fcf) will be used in the order in which they appear; SECOND RULE OF PRECEDENCE--ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, and SET ORIGIN tools will be applied in order; the program will attempt to use each datum feature first to eliminate pitch and yaw, then to eliminate roll, and then to eliminate the three degrees of translational freedom; RULE OF MAXIMUM UTILIZATION--each datum feature must contribute everything it can and may to eliminating the six degrees of freedom of a drf; RULE OF COMPOSITE feature CONTROL frames--datum features listed in a first tier of a composite feature control frame are empowered to remove both translational and rotational degrees of drf freedom; datum features listed in a second tier and all lower tiers of a composite feature control frame may only remove rotational degrees of freedom; RULE OF NON-OVERRIDE--no datum features may override degrees of freedom eliminated by previous datum features; RULE OF SIMULTANEITY--all features referenced to a same mobile drf must meet their requirements simultaneously unless modified by a notation indicating that they are separate; in the case of separate groups of features referenced to the same mobile drfs defined by second and lower tiers of separate composite feature control frames, the rule of simultaneity applies separately within each group. 55. A medium as in
(a) identifying a next datum feature in the sequence; (b) determining if pitch and yaw have already been eliminated; (c) if pitch and yaw have not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature is capable of eliminating pitch and yaw, applying an ORIENT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate pitch and yaw; (d) determining if roll has been eliminated; (e) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation;- (f) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with the material location modifier Independent of material location (IML), applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (g) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Basic material location (BML), Maximum material location (MML) or Least material location (LML), applying a PIVOT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's location; (h) determining if all degrees of translational freedom have been eliminated; (i) if all degrees of translational freedom have not been eliminated, applying a SET ORIGIN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate all permissible and possible degrees of translational freedom; (j) determining if all degrees of freedom have been eliminated; (k) if all degrees of freedom have not been eliminated and more datum features exist, repeating steps (a) to (j), otherwise terminating processing.
56. A medium as in
(a) identifying a next datum feature in the sequence; (b) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; (c) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Independent of material location (IML), applying an ALIGN tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's orientation; and (d) if roll has not been eliminated, and if said next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the drf, and if said next datum feature is associated with a material location modifier Basic material location (BML), Maximum material location (MML), or Least material location (LML), applying a PIVOT tool to said next datum feature to eliminate roll using said next datum feature's location.
|
This application is a continuation of application Ser. No. 08/709,099, filed on Sep. 6, 1996, now U.S. Pat. No. 5,949,693.
1. Field of the Invention
The present invention generally relates to the art of fabricating objects using machine tools, and more specifically to a Computer Aided Design (CAD) system for unambiguously constructing Feature Control Frames (FCF) and to Computer Aided Tolerance Analysis (CATA), Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM) and Computer Aided Inspection (CAI) systems for automatically constructing Datum Reference Frames (DRF) for machine parts.
2. Description of the Related Art
A machine part or object made of metal or other material is conventionally formed or machined using a motorized tool such as a press or a milling machine by immobilizing the part in a holding fixture, and engaging appropriate surfaces of the part with forming or cutting tools to move or remove material and thereby form the part into the required shape.
The precision with which a part must be manufactured can be extremely high, with tolerances often expressed in microinches. With such precision comes the need to accurately determine the location of the cutting tool relative the other features on the part. For example, if a hole must be drilled at a certain distance from an edge of a part, means must be provided to establish a frame of reference in which to measure this distance and accurately position the cutting tool.
This need is fulfilled by a Datum Reference Frame (DRF), which is a Cartesian coordinate system relative to which the locations and attitudes of machine part features are defined. Whereas one or more DRFs may be defined in each part, a DRF is not a physical entity, but rather an imaginary construct to which physical features on a part are geometrically related.
A system of standards has been established for dimensioning and tolerancing using DRFS. These standards are presented in a publication entitled "Dimensioning and Tolerancing", ASME Y14.5M-1994, American Society of Mechanical Engineers 1995. Further standards are set forth in a publication entitled "Mathematical Definition of Dimensioning and Tolerancing Principles", ASME Y14.5.1M-1994, American Society of Mechanical Engineers 1995. These publications are incorporated herein by reference in their entirety.
A DRF is defined by a small number, typically three, of specially selected features on a part called Datum Features (DF), which, if engaged by a holding fixture, render the part immobilized. The immobilizing components of a holding fixture or a functional gage can be seen as the inverses of the datum features, and are referred to as Datum Feature Simulators (DFS) The origin, axes, and planes of the DRF constructed with the help of said Datum Features are referred to as Datums.
For example, a planar surface of a part can be used as a primary datum feature to eliminate pitch, yaw, and one degree of translational freedom, with other datum features being used to eliminate the three remaining degrees of freedom which are roll and two additional degrees of translational freedom. The precise geometrical orientations and locations of the remaining features of the part are then controlled relative to the DRF so constructed.
Prior to machining or inspecting a part, a holding fixture or functional gage is produced. The part is clamped in said fixture such that its datum features mate with the datum feature simulators of the fixture, whereby the DRF of the part is brought into alignment with the DRF of the fixture and therefore with the coordinate system of the machine or measuring tool. This enables the features of the part to be reliably machined and inspected using the dimensions specified in the engineering blueprint or formal drawing.
The concept of a DRF can be better understood through the presentation of an illustrative example, which takes a simple part from the concept stage, through all the ensuing drawing, manufacturing and inspection stages.
At the outset, it is useful to make a simple perspective sketch of the part, which is shown in FIG. 1 and designated by the reference numeral 10. Further illustrated are an origin O and the X, Y and Z axes of a DRF which will serve to control the location of the part's features.
If the part 10 were handled at this point, it would be discovered that it has six Degrees of Freedom (DOF); it can pitch, yaw and roll (three degrees of rotational freedom), and translate in the X, Y and Z directions (three degrees of translational freedom). Since the coordinate system is attached to the part, it goes wherever the part goes, making it clear that coordinate systems also have six degrees of freedom.
The six degrees of freedom are illustrated in FIG. 2. In the particular case shown, pitch is about the Y axis, yaw about the X axis and roll about the Z axis. Translation is indicated by a coordinate system X',Y',Z' which is translated from the coordinate system X,Y,Z by offsets ΔX,ΔY,ΔZ.
In order to be manufactured, the conceptual part must be defined in a formal drawing or Computer Aided Design (CAD) data base. In addition to creating its general outlines and dimensions, it is important to select certain features to determine the coordinate system responsible for locating and orienting the other features.
The most reliable of such "datum" features are probably (1) the bottom of the part 10 which is designated by the reference character A, which can eliminate pitch, yaw, and one degree of translational freedom in the Z direction as indicated above; (2) a long edge B of the part 10 which can eliminate roll and one more degree of translational freedom in Y; and (3) a short edge C of the part 10 which can eliminate the last degree of translational freedom in X.
These edges are selected to constitute datum features A, B and C respectively, and control the remaining features using ASME Y14.5M tolerancing tools. A formal drawing of the part 10 is shown in
As viewed in
The FCF 14 further includes datum feature references 14a, in this case to the planar surfaces A, B and C. This specifies that a DRF for the part 10 is to be constructed using the datum features A, B and C in the order or sequence listed in the FCF. The formal drawing, including the FCF 14 with datum feature references 14a, is prepared by the engineer who designs the part 10, and must be adhered to exactly during all stages of the manufacture, inspection, etc. of the part 10.
Assuming that the part 10 is to be manufactured from a rough forged billet, it is secured in a milling machine vise (not shown), and the top surface is cleaned up using a rotary cutting tool 16 as illustrated in FIG. 4. This results in datum feature A, which coincides with the machine's X-Y base plane as soon as the Z axis of the machine's digital readout is reset to zero.
In the same set-up, the front surface is milled perpendicular to A and parallel to the machine's X axis. This results in datum feature B, which coincides with the machine's X-Z base plane once the Y axis of the machine's digital readout is reset to zero, after correcting for the tool radius. Repeating the process for the right hand surface, the datum feature C is produced.
Finishing the part at this point would consist of milling the remaining two sides, boring the hole 12, flipping the part 10 over, and cleaning up the top. However, if the machine were needed for other work before the job could be finished, and the unfinished part 10 would have to be removed from the machine, the relationship between the part 10's DRF and that of the machine would be lost.
This, however, is where datum features A, B and C come in. Since they define the part 10's reference frame, they can serve to reunite it with that of the machine.
This is accomplished by flipping the part 10 over and putting datum feature A down on the bottom of the vise to eliminate the part's pitch and yaw, after which the opposed surface may be milled to size in accordance with its Dimension Origin tolerance of 1.000±0.005.
Next, datum feature A is clamped against the back of the vise with datum feature B face down on the bottom of the vise. By so doing, datum feature A is used to eliminate pitch and yaw in a new way, and datum feature B, for the first time, to eliminate roll, creating the coordinate system in which the rear surface of the part can be milled to size in accordance with its surface profile tolerance.
Next, in preparation for the final operations, pitch and yaw are again eliminated by placing datum feature A back on the bottom of the vise, and roll by clamping datum feature B up against the back of the vise. With the help of an edgefinder to null the Y axis of the milling machine on the back of the vise and the X axis on the highest point of datum feature C, the remaining end of the part 10 can be milled to size in accordance with its surface profile tolerance, and the hole 16 bored in accordance with its position tolerance.
This example illustrates how datum features A, B and C, can be used to bring the DRF of the part 10 into coincidence with that of the machine for each operation, allowing its manufacture to be completed in strict observance of the requirements of the drawing.
When more than one datum feature is referenced in an FCF, they work in concert to construct a DRF, and it is important to recognize the significance of their sequence. In the FCF for position in the example of
Since elimination of pitch and yaw is of the greatest importance, the datum feature chosen for this must be large compared to the locations and extent of the features referred to it. Since the elimination of roll is of almost equal importance, the datum feature chosen for this must also be large compared to the locations and extent of the features referred to it. In the case of datum features used only to eliminate degrees of translational freedom, the smaller the better, to reduce uncertainty.
Even if these requirements for datum feature selection appear not to be observed in the drawing, the stated order of the datum features must nevertheless be respected by all who deal with the part, until changed by the design engineer. FCFs may thus not be "interpreted", but must be "read" in the same way by those involved in the manufacturing process as by those involved in the metrology process. Only this can insure one-to-one correspondence between the DRFs in each operation, without which the possibility of process control feedback collapses.
This concept is illustrated in
More specifically, in accordance with well defined procedures described in the referenced standards, the datum feature A is intended to eliminate pitch, yaw, and translation in the Z direction, the datum feature B is intended to eliminate roll and translation in the Y direction, and the datum feature C is intended to eliminate translation in the X direction of said part.
The drawing for the part 20 furthermore specifies a hole 22 which is to be drilled at a basic dimension of 3.000 inches from the datum feature C (equivalently 3.000 inches from the Y axis of the DRF), and 2.750 inches from the datum feature B (equivalently 2.750 inches from the X axis of the DRF).
As illustrated in
However, if during the inspection process the formal drawing is misread, and the datum feature C is used to eliminate roll, then, when the part 20 is placed in a requisite inspection fixture 26, as illustrated in
An important feature of the present invention relates to an ambiguity in the Y14.5.M and the Y14.5.1M standards and their international counterparts as to whether the orientation or the location of secondary and tertiary datum features should be used to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of a DRF. The current standards provide no means to differentiate between the two alternatives, thus leaving the matter open to interpretation and manufacturing companies exposed to the costly consequences thereof.
In a manner similar to
The one remaining degree of freedom is rotation about the fixed primary axis (Z axis) passing through the center of the hole 32. This degree of freedom is intended to be eliminated by the slot 34 which is designated as datum feature C. The slot 34 is to have a width of 0.500, and a nominal midplane which contains the axis of the hole 32. The slab-like tolerance zone within which the actual midplane must lie has a width of 0.020 inches.
Whereas either the orientation or the location of the slot 34 could serve to eliminate roll about the axis through the hole 32, the FCF fails to define a preferred alternative, and thus leads to the confusion described below.
Since the DFS 40 is free to translate, upon coming to rest its upper and lower surfaces end up parallel to the upper and lower surfaces of the slot 34. Thus, the orientation of the slot 34 is used to eliminate roll.
In
In
Since the actual slot 34 is offset upwardly from its basic location, the part 30 is caused to rotate clockwise as the now fixed DFS 40' expands in the slot 34 as shown in
Using orientation to eliminate roll in the manufacturing process, as in
This ambiguity has heretofore prevented practitioners in the art from providing a formal drawing including feature control frames which unambiguously define the preferred function-of datum features. The same omission has further prevented the implementation of a CAD or other computer system which can automatically construct a DRF.
It is therefore an object of the present invention to fulfill the need which has existed heretofore in the prior art by providing a computer implemented method for unambiguously specifying and automatically constructing a Datum Reference Frame (DRF) for a machine part.
In accordance with the present invention, a formal drawing for a machine part includes a Feature Control Frame (FCF) which identifies the datum features required to construct a Datum Reference Frame (DRF) for the part, and in the case of a datum feature intended to eliminate roll about a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, provides for a material location modifier which specifies whether the associated Datum Feature Simulator is to be fixed or free to float in a direction perpendicular to its basic axis, midplane or surface, and thus whether the orientation or the location of the datum feature should be used to eliminate roll.
The material location modifiers enable specification of Independent of Material Location (IML), at Basic Material Location (BML), at Maximum Material Location (MML) and at Least Material Location (LML), and thereby eliminate any possibility of misinterpretation of the formal drawing during all stages of manufacture and inspection of the part. Computer programs implementing a method of the invention include instructions (1) for assisting in the construction of rational FCFs based on selected datum features belonging to a mathematical model of a part defined in a CAD environment, and (2) for automatically constructing unambiguous DRFs in Computer Aided Tolerance Analysis (CATA), Computer Aided Manufacturing (CAM) and Computer Aided Inspection (CAI) environments in response to the dimensions, tolerances, datum feature sequence and material location modifiers listed in a FCF, using a set of specific DRF construction tools and rules.
The tools for DRF construction include ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, SET ORIGIN, TRANSLATE and ROTATE, and are applied in order to sequentially eliminate pitch, yaw, roll, and three degrees of translation freedom from the DRF.
The rules for DRF construction include: RULE OF MATERIAL ORIENTATION, RULES OF MATERIAL LOCATION, RULES OF MATERIAL CONDITION, FIRST RULE OF PRECEDENCE, SECOND RULE OF PRECEDENCE, RULE OF MAXIMUM UTILIZATION, RULE OF COMPOSITE FEATURE CONTROL FRAMES, RULE OF NON-OVERRIDE, and RULE OF SIMULTANEITY.
These and other features and advantages of the present invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art from the following detailed description, taken together with the accompanying drawings, in which like reference numerals refer to like parts.
The construction of Datum Reference Frames (DRF) is fundamental for the management of machine part geometry. Two kinds of DRF construction processes can be defined. The first might be called "natural", representing the natural, physical process of nesting a part in a manufacturing fixture in strict accordance with the "Rules of Natural DRF Construction" implied in the Y14.5M and Y14.5.1M standards. The second might be called "artificial", representing processes which may be desirable, but contravene the "Rules of Natural DRF Construction".
Whereas the "natural" process has always been assumed to be clearly defined, failure to deal unambiguously with certain secondary and tertiary datum features (DF), as exemplified by the controversy over the "interpretation" of the well known "hockey puck" (see ASME Y14.5.1M
In fact, both alternatives are of interest, and the question is how to distinguish between them in order to eliminate this last source of ambiguity in specifying "natural" DRFs.
DRF Construction Concepts
Datum Reference Frame (DRF) construction is the process of orderly reduction of the three degrees of rotational and three degrees of translational freedom of Cartesian coordinate systems by means of and as affected by the degrees of rotational, translational and material condition freedom of selected datum features.
Definition I: The process of "natural" DRF construction (1) is currently defined by the datum feature labels and Material Condition Modifiers listed in a Feature Control Frame, (2) is accomplished by the sequential engagement of the referenced datum features by the associated datum features of the mating part or by the datum feature simulators of a functional gage, and (3) is governed by certain rules and natural laws, some of which are explicitly defined in the Y14.5.1M standard (§4.4.2, §4.5 and §4.6 on p. 17).
Definition II: The process of "artificial" DRF construction is identical to that of "natural" DRF construction except that the natural power of datum features to eliminate degrees of DRF freedom is artificially limited with the help of symbolic, graphic or English language indicators. The rules concerning Composite Feature Control Frames are an example of "artificial" DRF construction currently defined in the Y14.5M and Y14.5.1M standards, to wit: whereas the datum features referenced in the first tier of a Composite Feature Control Frame must eliminate both translational and rotational degrees of freedom, those referenced in the second and lower tiers may only eliminate rotational degrees of freedom.
Thesis: The ongoing uncertainty in "natural" DRF construction, and the limitations plaguing "artificial" DRF Construction are caused by:
1. Inadequacy of current Feature Control Frame symbology to completely define the requirements.
2. Lack of a complete set of clearly defined DRF construction tools.
3. Lack of a complete set of explicit DRF construction rules.
Proposal I: "Natural" DRF construction can be made completely unambiguous by:
1. Extending ASME Y14.5M defined Feature Control Frame symbology through the addition of Material Location Modifiers to augment the existing Material Condition Modifiers.
2. Defining explicit "natural" DRF construction tools, which mimic the natural DRF construction processes of functional gages and fixtures.
3. Explicitly stating the "natural" DRF construction rules and laws which control the application of said tools.
Proposal II: Artificial DRF construction can be facilitated by:
1. Extending ASME Y14.5M (ISO 1101) defined Feature Control Frame symbology through the addition of Degrees of Freedom modifiers to augment the proposed Material Location Modifiers and the existing Material Condition Modifiers.
2. Explicitly stating the "artificial" DRF construction rules and laws which control the application of said modifiers.
The Natural DRF Construction Process
Although it is well known that DRFs are constructed by eliminating as many of their six degrees of freedom as the datum features in a particular Feature Control Frame (FCF) will permit, it is essential to understand the process explicitly. The foundation of the DRF construction process is the concept of nesting the datum features of the considered part in the datum features of the mating part, thus orienting and locating all the features of both parts relative to one another. By extension, we can substitute a machining fixture or a functional gage for the mating part, and thus focus on DRF related manufacturing and inspection processes. In the following we limit ourselves to the functional gage, and to treatment of its DRF construction components. These are commonly referred to as datum feature simulators (DFS), and are simply the inverses of the datum features they serve to engage. Thus the DFS for a planar datum feature is a plane oriented in the opposite direction, the DFS for a bore is a shaft and that for a shaft is a bore.
With the help of the functional gage concept it is possible to understand that the listing of datum feature labels and their modifiers in FCFs serves three purposes: (1) to identify the datum features intended to construct a particular DRF, (2) to specify the geometric characteristics and behavior of the datum feature simulators intended to engage said datum features, and (3) to specify the order in which said engagement is to be accomplished during DRF construction.
The definition of the "geometric characteristics and behavior of datum feature simulators" comes partly from the drawing or CAD model, and partly from the modifiers associated with each datum feature label in a FCF. In particular, the geometric nature and the basic orientations and locations of the datum feature simulators are defined by the CAD model itself, whereas the instructions concerning their behavior are stored FCFs in the form of datum feature modifiers. The current world standards for geometric dimensioning and tolerancing recognize only one type of datum feature modifier called "Material Condition Modifiers" (MCM). These determine whether a datum feature simulator which simulates a datum feature with size is to be fixed in size or is to be free to expand or contract to consume all the space available in or outside said datum feature during the process of DRF construction. The current proposal introduces a new set of modifiers called "Material Location Modifiers" (MLM), with which the remaining ambiguity in the current standard can be completely eliminated. As will be demonstrated, said Material Location Modifiers serve to determine whether datum feature simulators shall be fixed or shall be free to translate during the process of DRF construction.
The Artificial DRF Construction Process
Whereas "natural" DRF construction foresees requiring each datum feature to remove as many degrees of DRF freedom as it can and may under the rules of "natural" DRF construction referenced herein, the artificial DRF construction extension envisions providing the designer with the freedom to construct DRFs in "unnatural" or completely artificial ways. The method for so doing involves extending the datum feature modifier concept to Include Degrees of Freedom Modifiers (DFM) in addition to the aforementioned Material Condition Modifiers (MCM) and Material Location Modifiers (MLM). In accordance with this extension, DFMs are appended to the datum features referenced in a FCF in the same manner as are MCMs and MLMs, and specify those degrees of freedom which a particular datum feature may remove or those which it may not remove.
Material Condition Modifiers (MCM)
The current Y14.5.1 standard includes Material Condition Modifiers (MCM) for datum features with size which will be presented with reference to
The material condition modifiers include Regardless of Feature Size (RFS) [in essence "Regardless of Material Condition" (MC)], at Maximum Material Condition (MMC) and at Least Material Condition (LMC).
When a datum feature with size is referenced in a FCF accompanied by the Material Condition Modifier RFS (the default condition in the Y14.5M 1994 standard), the design engineer has stipulated that the actual size of the feature is not permitted to influence DRF construction, and thus that the implied datum feature simulator shall expand or contract to fill any available space. When a datum feature with size is referenced in a FCF accompanied by a Maximum Material Condition Modifier, the design engineer has stipulated that the actual size of the feature is intended to influence DRF construction, and that the implied datum feature simulator shall be fixed at Virtual Material Condition, in this case the Maximum Material Condition of the datum feature plus (in the case of external features) or minus (in the case of internal features) any applicable tolerance on its location or orientation. When a datum feature with size is referenced in a FCF accompanied by a Least Material Condition Modifier, the design engineer has stipulated that the actual size of the feature is again intended to influence DRF construction, and that the implied datum feature simulator shall again be fixed at Virtual Material Condition, in this case the Least Material Condition of the datum feature plus (in the case of internal features) or minus (in the case of external features) any applicable tolerance on its location or orientation.
The concepts of MMC and LMC are presented in
The MMC of the width of the part 50, in which the part 50 has the most material, is 5.000 inches plus the upper tolerance of 0.010 inches or 5.010 inches. The LMC, in which the part 50 has the least material, is 5.000 inches minus the lower tolerance of 0.010 inches or 4.990 inches.
The MMC of the width of the slot, in which the part 50 taken as a whole has the most material, is 1.000-0.010=0.990 inch. The LMC, in which the part 50 taken as a whole has the least material, is 1.000+0.010=1.010 inch. It will be noted that at maximum material condition, the width of the slot 52 is the smallest, and at least material condition, the largest.
As indicated at 54', the hole 54 is at MMC when its diameter is equal to the nominal diameter (1.000 inch) minus the lower tolerance (0.020 inch)=0.980 inch.
As indicated at 54", the hole 54 is at LMC when its diameter is equal to the nominal diameter (1.000 inch) plus the upper diameter tolerance (0.020 inch)=1.020 inch.
As indicated at 58' the rod 58 is at MMC when its diameter is equal to the nominal diameter (1.000 inch) plus the upper diameter tolerance (0.020 inch)=Ø1.020 inch.
As indicated at 58" the rod 58 is at LMC when its diameter is equal to nominal diameter (1.000 inch) minus the lower diameter tolerance (0.020 inch)=Ø0.980 inch.
Material Location Modifiers (MLM)
Although the current Y14.5 standard includes Material Condition Modifiers (MCM) as described above, it does not include Material Location Modifiers (MLM) which are introduced in accordance with the present invention to eliminate the ambiguity regarding whether the orientation or location of secondary and tertiary datum features should be used to eliminate roll. The invention envisions four MCMs; Independent of Material Location (IML), at Basic Material Location (BML), at Maximum Material Location (MML) and at Least Material Location (LML).
In operation, the modifier IML stipulates that the implied datum feature simulator shall be free to translate perpendicular to its basic axis, midplane or surface as it attempts to eliminate roll. The modifier BML, where applicable, stipulates that the implied datum feature simulator be fixed at its basic location as it attempts to eliminate roll. The modifiers MML and LML, where applicable, stipulate that the implied datum feature simulator be fixed at its Virtual Material Location as it attempts to eliminate roll.
Whereas the modifiers IML and BML apply to features with and without size, the modifiers MML and LML apply only to features without size.
Whereas the meanings of IML and at BML are obvious, the following explanation is required for MML and LML. A planar feature is at MML when it is located such that the associated part has the most material associated with it. Similarly, a planar feature is at LML when it is located such that the associated part has the least material associated with it.
The MLM and LML concepts of the invention are illustrated in
Illustrating the above definitions, the planar surface 70a is at MML when located a distance 2.010 inches from the hole 72 and at LML when located a distance 1.990 inches from the hole 72.
Examples of the Effects of MLMs
(1) A straddling planar DF referenced IML defines an opposed planar DFS which is free to translate toward the DF until brought to a stop, causing the orientation of the DF to be responsible for eliminating roll.
(2) A straddling planar DF referenced at MML defines an opposed planar DFS which is fixed at the VML of said DF, causing the orientation of said DF to eliminate roll, with the location of said DF determining the degree of residual roll in the DRP.
(3) A non-straddling, slot-like DF referenced RFS and IML, defines a slab-like DFS which is free to expand (RFS) inside the DF, and free to translate perpendicular to the mid-plane of said DFS until the DFS has consumed all the space available inside the DF at which point the object and DFS have come to rest, in effect using the orientation of the DF to eliminate roll.
(4) A non-straddling, slot-like DF referenced RFS and at BML defines a slab-like DFS which is fixed (BML) at the basic location of the DF, but is free to expand (RFS) inside the DF until the DFS has consumed all the space available inside the DF, at which point the object has come to rest, in effect using the location of the DF to eliminate roll.
Natural DRF Construction Requirements
In the case of datum features of all types, it must be known whether the associated datum feature simulators are to be
(1) fixed in orientation relative to one another, or free to pitch, yaw or roll, and (2) fixed in location relative to one another, or free to translate in a direction perpendicular to their axes, mid-planes or planar surfaces. In the case of datum features with size, it must also be known whether the associated datum feature simulators are to be (3) fixed at virtual condition, or required to expand or contract to consume all the space available in or around the related datum feature.
The current Y14.5M standard uses the material condition modifiers "M" and "L", or the absence thereof, to unambiguously address requirement (3). Furthermore, although it fails to say so explicitly, the current standard clearly implies that all DFSs be fixed at their BASIC orientations, and therefore essentially addresses requirement (1).
However, the current standard lacks any means for specifying whether datum feature simulators are to be fixed in location or not, and thus leaves requirement (2) open to "interpretation". In some cases, a particular interpretation is so well embedded as to be difficult to identify as an interpretation; in others, the alternative interpretations are obvious as in the case of the "hockey puck" problem described above with reference to
Preliminary Concepts and Definitions
As stated above, the ambiguity in the Y14.5M and related standards has to do with inadequate means for specifying how secondary and tertiary datum features are intended to eliminate DRF roll. The method of the present invention includes introducing the above described set of material location modifiers in parallel with the existing material condition modifiers.
Designating datum features A and B as primary and secondary respectively, the tertiary datum features identified in TABLE I below demonstrate significantly different characteristics which determine their significantly differing ability to eliminate DRF roll. For example, either the orientation or the location of datum features D and E could serve to eliminate roll, but only the locations of F and H1 can do so.
It can also be seen that the orientations p datum features C and G are primarily responsible for eliminating roll, but that their locations have an effect as well. Although easily demonstrated in common assembly situations, this is a condition undefined in the current Y14.5M standard, but easily dealt with by the present material location modifiers.
TABLE I | ||||||
Unit Vector | ||||||
relative to | ||||||
the Primary | Location relative to | |||||
Feature | Feature | DRF Axis | the Primary DRF Axis | |||
Name | w. Size | w/o Size | PRL | PPD | Non-straddling | Straddling |
C | -- | X | -- | X | -- | X |
D | X | -- | -- | X | X | -- |
E | -- | X | -- | X | X | -- |
F | X | -- | X | -- | X | -- |
G | X | -- | -- | X | -- | X |
H1 | -- | X | -- | X | X | -- |
As will become clear from subsequent description, it is important in the case of roll eliminating secondary and tertiary datum features to differentiate between those which "straddle" versus those which do not straddle the primary DRF axis because of the different treatment they will naturally demand.
For the purposes of the invention we define a datum feature as "straddling" if the normal projection of the primary axis onto the feature intersects the feature's axis, center plane or surface, and otherwise as "non-straddling". As a consequence, the special case of a feature whose axis is parallel to the primary axis is non-straddling. These alternatives are illustrated in FIG. 10.
From this definition it is evident from
Natural DRF Construction Tools & Rules
The construction of DRFs can be accomplished by a set of conceptual tools which mimic the defining process of nesting a machine part in a functional gage. These tools are either vectorial in nature or simulate the functional gaging process directly using computer based part and gage models. The vectorial process uses the tools tabulated in TABLE II, to build the founding DRF. If required, the vectorial process provides the springboard for refining the founding DRF with the help of functional gage simulation. This addresses residual DRF mobility arising from among other causes, (1) an insufficient number of datum features to remove all six degrees of freedom, (2) the mobilizing effects of certain Material Condition and Material Location Modifiers under certain circumstances, and (3) the mobilizing effects of imperfect datum feature form.
TABLE II | |
Natural DRF Construction Tools | |
ORIENT | to eliminate Pitch and Yaw |
ALIGN | to eliminate Roll using the orientation of a Datum |
Feature | |
PIVOT | to eliminate Roll using the location of a Datum Feature |
SET ORIGIN | to eliminate all three degrees of translational freedom |
TRANSLATE | to shift a DRF along its axes by BASIC dimensions |
ROTATE | to swivel a DRF about an axis by a BASIC angle |
The tools are implemented by applying them in succession to each datum feature listed in a feature control frame in an effort to eliminate as many degrees of DRF freedom as possible and permissible. The ORIENT tool uses the orientation of a datum feature to eliminate pitch and yaw; the ALIGN tool uses the orientation of a datum feature to eliminate roll, and so on. Hardly coincidentally, these are common names for the same tools used to construct DRFs in Coordinate Measuring Machine software systems.
The ORIENT tool eliminates pitch and yaw, and is illustrated in
The ALIGN tool eliminates roll using the orientation of a datum feature, and is illustrated in
The PIVOT tool eliminates roll using the location of a datum feature and is illustrated in
The SET ORIGIN tool eliminates one or more degrees of translational freedom and is illustrated in
The TRANSLATE and ROTATE tools are used merely to re-rotate the axes and shift the origin of a previously constructed DRF in order to bring it into line with a Cartesian coordinate system of a machine tool, inspection machine, CAD representation, etc., and are not explicitly illustrated.
It can be proven that these six tools are both necessary and sufficient for the construction of all static and mobile DRFs when used in conjunction with the Rules of Natural DRF Construction which are listed below. Rules 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9 are either explicitly or implicitly defined in the ASME Y14.5M 1994 standard. The remaining rule 2 is an integral element of the present invention.
Rules of Natural DRF Construction
1. RULE OF MATERIAL ORIENTATION--the orientations of datum feature simulators are fixed relative to one another at the BASIC angles of their corresponding datum features;
2. RULES OF MATERIAL LOCATION
(i) datum feature simulators which do not serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums.
(ii) all datum feature simulators representing datum targets are fixed at their basic locations relative to previously established datums.
(iii) the manner in which datum feature simulators serve to eliminate roll relative to a previously fixed primary axis of a DRF is determined by explicit Material Location Modifiers or by Material Location Modifier defaults.
3. RULE OF MATERIAL CONDITION--datum feature simulators representing datum features with size are fixed at Virtual Material Condition (VMC) if accompanied by Maximum Material Condition (MMC) or Least Material Condition (LMC) modifiers, and will otherwise expand or contract to consume all space inside or outside respective datum features;
4. FIRST RULE OF PRECEDENCE--datum features listed in a Feature Control Frame (FCF) will be used in the order in which they appear;
5. SECOND RULE OF PRECEDENCE--the tools ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, and SET ORIGIN will be applied to each datum feature in the order shown in an attempt first to eliminate pitch and yaw, then to eliminate roll, and then to eliminate the three degrees of translational freedom;
6. RULE OF MAXIMUM UTILIZATION--each datum feature must contribute everything it can and may to eliminating the six degrees of freedom of a DRF;
7. RULE OF COMPOSITE FEATURE CONTROL FRAMES--datum features listed in a first tier of a composite feature control frame are empowered to remove both translational and rotational degrees of DRF freedom; datum features listed in a second tier and all lower tiers of a composite feature control frame may only remove rotational degrees of freedom;
8. RULE OF NON-OVERRIDE--no datum features may override degrees of freedom eliminated by previous datum features;
9. RULE OF SIMULTANEITY--all features referenced to a same mobile DRF must meet their requirements simultaneously unless modified by a notation indicating that they are separate; in the case of separate groups of features referenced to the same mobile DRFs defined by second and lower tiers of separate composite feature control frames, the, rule of simultaneity applies separately within each group.
Physical Process for Constructing a DRF
The part 100 has a flat bottom A, and edges C and K, which constitute planar datum features, as well as a central hole to be drilled relative to a DRF which is constructed using the datum features A, C and K. The functional gage 102 consists of slabs 104, 106 and 108 having functional gage components A', C' and K' constituted by surfaces thereof respectively.
The first DRF construction step is to place datum feature A of the part 100 on the functional gage component A' of the slab 104 as shown in
The second step is to push datum feature C up against the functional gage element C' of the slab 106 to eliminate the remaining degree of rotational freedom (roll), and one more degree of translational freedom in the Y direction, being careful not to override the previous elimination of pitch and yaw.
The third step is to push datum feature K up against the functional gage element K' of the slab 108 to eliminate the remaining degree of translational freedom in the X direction, being careful not to override the previous elimination of roll, pitch and yaw.
This process demonstrates the First Rule of Precedence governing the order in which the datum features are to be used, the Rule of Maximum Utilization, in which each datum feature must contribute everything it can to DRF construction, and the Rule of Non-Override, barring succeeding datum features from altering previously eliminated degrees of DRF freedom.
Conceptual Process for Constructing a DRF
A DRF can also be constructed "conceptually" thus without a physical functional gage, using the computer system of a coordinate measuring machine to process data collected from individual datum feature surfaces.
As real machine parts or objects do not have perfect geometry, the coordinate measuring machine must simulate the function of physical DFSs by contacting the three highest points on the primary datum feature, the two highest on the secondary datum feature and the single highest point on the tertiary datum feature of the part 100.
As shown in
The SET ORIGIN tool is then used to move the origin of the 1st interim coordinate system into said plan through the three highest points on datum feature A, eliminating the first degree of translational freedom in the Z direction, and creating a 2nd interim coordinate system (X2, Y2, Z2).
The ALIGN tool is used to make the X axis of the 2nd interim coordinate system parallel to the orientation of the line through the two highest points on datum feature C, eliminating the last degree of rotational freedom (roll), and creating a 3rd interim coordinate system (X3, Y3, Z3).
The SET ORIGIN tool is then used to move the origin of the 3rd interim coordinate system into said line through the two highest points on datum feature C, eliminating one more degree of translational freedom in the Y direction, and creating a 4th interim coordinate system (X4, Y4, Z4).
Finally, the SET ORIGIN tool is used to move the origin of the 4th interim coordinate system in to the highest point on datum feature K, eliminating the last degree of translational freedom in the X direction, and creating a 5th and final coordinate system (X5, Y5, Z5).
Material Location Modifier Alternatives
As described above, means have been heretofore available for designating the conditions under which the "size" of a datum feature is intended to influence the construction of a DRF. Namely, if a datum feature with size is referenced Regardless of Material Condition (RMC) [i.e. Regardless of Feature Size (RFS)], the associated datum feature simulator is required to expand or contract to consume all the space available. This always leads to complete elimination of the associated degrees of freedom.
On the other hand, if a datum feature with size is referenced at Maximum Material Condition (MMC), the associated datum feature simulator is to be frozen in size at Virtual Material Condition (VMC), resulting in an ever looser fit as the datum feature departs from VMC, and thus to a partially mobile DRF. The same applies conceptually in the case of Least Material Condition (LMC) datum feature modifiers.
Since datum features are possessed of orientation and location as well as size, the manner in which these characteristics are intended to influence the construction-of DRFs must also be addressed. Every indication in the Y14.5M standard and all common practice implies that the orientation of datum feature simulators shall be fixed at the basic angles of their associated datum features. The Rule of Material Orientation set forth above provides a simple means for formally eliminating this source of potential confusion.
However the need has remained in the prior art to institute rules which determine whether datum feature simulators are to be fixed or free to translate during DRF construction. In the interest of maintaining the integrity of the current system, it seems advisable to incorporate the means for expressing the designer's intent in this regard into the symbology of the feature control frame. Thus, the present invention adds a set of material location modifiers to the existing set of material condition modifiers. As will become clear in the following sections, the proposed material location modifiers completely eliminate the remaining ambiguity surrounding "natural" DRF construction.
In particular, the new material location modifiers will enable the designer to specify whether (1) the orientation or (2) the location of the slot in the "hockey puck" is to be used to eliminate DRF roll, in addition to providing a host of new design alternatives.
Three alternative defaults and therefore three alternative possible sets of material location modifier symbols and Rules of Material Location are provided within the scope of the present invention, as follows.
1. "Floating": all datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate roll about a previously fixed DRF axis are free to "float" (translate) in a direction perpendicular to their basic axes, mid-planes or surfaces.
2. "Fixed & Floating": all datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate roll about a previously fixed DRF axis and representing "non-straddling" datum features are locked at their basic locations, whereas those which represent "straddling" datum features are free to float in a direction perpendicular to their basic axes, midplanes or surfaces.
3. "Fixed": all datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate roll about a previously fixed DRF axis are "fixed" at the basic locations of their defining datum features.
The "Fixed & Floating" default requires two new explicit modifiers: (B) and (I), whereas the "Floating" default requires only the new explicit modifier (B), and the "Fixed" default requires only the new explicit modifier (I). Although requiring a greater number of explicit modifiers, the "Fixed & Floating" default requires the fewest changes to existing drawings under the current 1994 standard and is perhaps the most natural of the three, in that it is natural to think of datum feature simulators which represent non-straddling datum features as fixed, and those which represent straddling datum features as floating.
It is further within the scope of the invention to have no default modifiers, and require that all modifiers be stated explicitly.
Material Location Modifier Alternative I--Default: "Floating"
In the "Floating" default scenario, all datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate roll relative to a fixed primary axis are free to translate perpendicular to their basic axes, mid-planes or surfaces unless explicitly constrained. The unconstrained, default condition is represented by the material location modifier IML (Independent of Material Location), just as the default for unconstrained size is represented in the Y14.5 standard by the Material Condition Modifier RFS (herein replaced for consistency by the modifier RMC for "Regardless of Material Condition").
In addition, the constraints which may be required on the location of datum feature simulators are applied with the help of the following additional material location modifiers as described above: BML (at BASIC Material Location) for features with size, as well as for non-straddling features without size, and MML (at Maximum Material Location) and LML (at Least Material Location) for all features without size. TABLES III to VII, taken in combination with
TABLE III | ||||
"Floating" Material Condition & Location Modifiers | ||||
for Natural DRF Construction | ||||
Short | Long | |||
Form | Form | Full | Meaning | Applies to: |
default | RC | RMC | Regardless of Material | any feature with size |
Condition (RFS) | ||||
M | MC | MMC | at Maximum Material | any feature with size |
Condition | ||||
L | LC | LMC | at Least Material | any feature with size |
Condition | ||||
default | IL | IML | Independent of | any feature with or |
Material Location | w/o size | |||
B | BL | BML | at BASIC Material | any feature with size + |
Location | "non-straddling" | |||
w/o size | ||||
M | ML | MML | at Maximum Material | any feature w/o size |
Location | ||||
L | LL | LML | at Least Material | any feature w/o size |
Location | ||||
In the "Floating" default scenario, the modifiers (I) and (B) are added to the classical Y14.5M 1994 symbol set, and the use of the modifiers (M) and (L) is extended to apply to the location of datum features without size. Since the modifier (I) is always implied, the modifier (B) must be used expressly to arrest datum feature simulators which are not intended to "float". There is no danger of confusion between (M) used for MMC and (M) used for MML, or between (L) used for LMC and (L) used for LML, because the former apply only to features with size, and the latter only to features without size. The combination of the "Floating" default and the new material location modifiers enables the following.
Rules of Material Location ("Floating" Default)
1. All Datum Feature Simulators representing Datum Targets are fixed at their BASIC locations relative to previously established Datums.
2. All Datum Feature Simulators which do not serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis are fixed at their BASIC locations relative to previously established Datums.
3. All Datum Feature Simulators which serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis shall be free to float in a direction perpendicular to their basic axes, mid-planes or surfaces, unless associated with the Material Location Modifiers (B), (M) or (L), used as set forth in the table above.
Examples of "Floating" Default Alternative
To demonstrate the implications of the "Floating" default alternative, four different scenarios are presented as illustrated in
1.
These figures illustrate the effects on DRF construction of a rotation of datum feature D about a vertical axis through the its midpoint by -15°C, 0°C, and +15°C.
In this default scenario, by saying nothing (the invisible symbols for IML and RMC), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage datum feature D be free to translate and expand to consume all the space inside D, thus making its orientation responsible for eliminating roll. Changes in the orientation of datum feature D have no effect on the DRF. This alternative creates a static DRF (to the extent D is not wedge-shaped), represents the "Y14.5.1 interpretation" illustrated in
As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
2.
These figures illustrate the effects on DRF construction as a construction of a shift in the Y location of datum feature E relative to datum feature B from 1.240 to 1.250 to 1.260.
In the "Floating" default scenario by saying nothing (the invisible symbol for IML), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage datum feature E be free to translate until stability is achieved, thus making the orientation of E responsible for eliminating roll, regardless of its location. This alternative creates a static DRF to the extent E is not a "rocker" and is shown in
Adding the modifier (B) to datum feature E for @BML creates an equally static DRF in which the location of E is responsible for eliminating roll. This is accomplished by pivoting datum feature E about datum feature B until it runs up against the associated DFS fixed at E's basic location as shown in
Adding a stand-alone (M) to datum feature E for @MML, or (L) for @LML produces the same effect, except in these cases by pivoting datum feature E until it runs up against a DFS fixed at the feature's VML as illustrated in
3.
These figures illustrate the effect on DRF construction of a change in the width of datum feature G from 4.010 to 4.000 to 3.900 with a commensurate shift in the center plane from -0.005 to 0.000 to +0.005.
In the "Floating" default scenario, by saying nothing (the invisible symbols for IML and RMC), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage G be free to translate and contract to consume all the space outside G, thus making the orientation of the entire feature responsible for eliminating roll. This alternative creates a static DRF to the extent G is not wedge- or barrel-shaped , and is shown in
As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
4.
These figures illustrate the effects on DRF construction of a shift in the location of datum feature C relative to B from 1.990 to 2.000 to 2.010.
In the "Floating" default scenario, by saying nothing (the invisible symbol for IML), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage C be free to translate until stability is achieved, thus making the orientation of C responsible for eliminating roll, independent of its location. This is the standard interpretation of this scenario, and leads to a static DRF to the extent C is not convex (a "rocker"). It is illustrated in
As shown in
In summary,
All examples use the following abbreviations: The symbols used in the column labeled "Conceptual DRF Construction Commands" are to be understood as follows: OR=ORIENT, AL=ALIGN, PI=PIVOT, SOX, SOY and SOZ=SET ORIGIN in X, Y, and Z respectively.
The symbols used in the column labeled "Material Condition Dependent Mobility" are to be understood as follows: ΔX, ΔY, ΔZ stand for residual Material Condition and Material Location induced translational mobility along DRF X, Y and Z, axes respectively, whereas Δa stands for minimal and ΔΔa for significant residual roll mobility.
(Datum feature simulators) bear the same labels as their associated datum features, but with the addition of an apostrophe. The labels are to be read as: datum feature A and datum feature simulator A'.
TABLE IVa | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
17a | ABD | ABD | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced RMC | |||
D (Rc) (1L) | AL | -- | Expanding Mandrel D' Floating in Y | (default) and IML | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | (default), the | ||||||
at their BASIC relative | functional gage | ||||||
orientations! | element representing | ||||||
it is free to | |||||||
translate as it | |||||||
expands, insuring | |||||||
that the orientation | |||||||
of D will serve to | |||||||
eliminate Roll, thus | |||||||
indicating the use of | |||||||
the ALIGN tool. This | |||||||
represents the | |||||||
Y14.5.1 | |||||||
interpretation of ABD | |||||||
as shown in |
|||||||
of the Y14.5.1M | |||||||
standard, and | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
clearly leads to this | |||||||
unique alternative. | |||||||
See FIG. 17a. | |||||||
TABLE IVb | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Propoed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
17b | ABD | ABD | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced RMC | |||
D (Rc) (BL) | P1 | -- | Expanding Mandrel D' Fixed in Y | (default) and @ BML, | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | the functional gage | ||||||
at their BASIC relative | element representing | ||||||
orientations! | it is fixed relative | ||||||
to B as it expands, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
location of D will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, thus indicating | |||||||
the use of the PIVOT | |||||||
tool. This | |||||||
represents "the | |||||||
other" common | |||||||
interpretation of ABD | |||||||
which differs | |||||||
radically from that | |||||||
shown in FIG. 17a, | |||||||
and illustrates how | |||||||
the Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
clearly differentiates | |||||||
between the two. See | |||||||
FIG. 17a. | |||||||
TABLE IVc | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
17c | ABD | ABD (M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
(M) | B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced at MMC | ||
D (Mc) (1L) | AL (?) (P1 | ΔΔα | VMC Mandrel D' Floating in Y | and IML (default), the | |||
(?) | All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | functional gage | |||||
(+ Mobility | at their BASIC relative | element representing | |||||
Adjust- | orientations! | it will be at VMC and | |||||
ment) | free to float in Y, | ||||||
thus providing no | |||||||
clear cut means for | |||||||
eliminating Roll. | |||||||
Although this | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
defines a completely | |||||||
unambiguous | |||||||
alternative, this | |||||||
happens to be one | |||||||
worth avoiding. | |||||||
TABLE IVd | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
17d | ABD | ABD (M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
(M) | (B) | B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced at MMC | |
D (Mc) (BL) | P1 | Δα | VMC Mandrel D' Fixed in Y | and at BML, the | |||
(+ Mobility | All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | functional gage | |||||
Adjust- | at their BASIC relative | element representing | |||||
ment) | orientations! | it is fixed in size | |||||
(VMC) and in location | |||||||
relative to B, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
location of D will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, this indicating | |||||||
the use of the PIVOT | |||||||
tool. In this case D | |||||||
is a reliable roll | |||||||
controlling feature, | |||||||
allowing only a small | |||||||
degree of rotational | |||||||
mobility as D departs | |||||||
from MMC. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
clearly defines the | |||||||
preferable of two | |||||||
possible | |||||||
interpretations of | |||||||
the sequence AB | |||||||
(M)D. | |||||||
TABLE Va | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
18a | ABE | ABE | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because E is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced IML | |||
E (1L) | AL | -- | Plane E' Floating in Y | (default), the | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be | functional gage | ||||||
frozen at their BASIC relative | element representing | ||||||
orientations! | it is free to | ||||||
translate until E is | |||||||
parallel to it, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
orientation of E | |||||||
will serve to | |||||||
eliminate Roll, and | |||||||
indicating the use | |||||||
of the ALIGN tool. | |||||||
This illustrates how | |||||||
the Material | |||||||
Location Modifier | |||||||
method clearly | |||||||
defines the first of | |||||||
the two possible | |||||||
interpretations of | |||||||
the common sequence | |||||||
ABE. See also FIG. | |||||||
18b. | |||||||
TABLE Vb | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
18b | ABE | ABE (B) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because E is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced at BML, | |||
E (BL) | P1 | -- | Plane E' Fixed in Y at BML | the functional gage | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be | element it is fixed | ||||||
frozen at their BASIC relative | in Y, insuring that | ||||||
orientations! | the location of E | ||||||
will serve to | |||||||
eliminate Roll, and | |||||||
indicating the use | |||||||
of the PIVOT tool. | |||||||
This illustrates how | |||||||
the Material | |||||||
Location Modifier | |||||||
method clearly | |||||||
defines the second | |||||||
of the two possible | |||||||
interpretations of | |||||||
the common sequence | |||||||
ABE. See also FIG. | |||||||
18a. | |||||||
18c | ABE | ABE (M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | As in |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | location of E serves | |||
E (ML) | P1 | -- | Plane E' Fixed in Y at MML | to eliminate Roll, | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be | however in this case | ||||||
frozen at their BASIC relative | the DFS representing | ||||||
orientations! | it is fixed at the | ||||||
MMC Virtual Material | |||||||
Location. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
provides additional | |||||||
design freedom. | |||||||
TABLE Vc | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
18d | ABE | ABE (L) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | As in |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | location of E serves | |||
E (LL) | P1 | -- | Plane E' Fixed in Y at LML | to eliminate Roll, | |||
(+ Mobility | All DFSs are assumed to be | however in this case | |||||
Adjust- | frozen at their BASIC relative | the DFS representing | |||||
ment) | orientations! | it is fixed at the | |||||
LMC Virtual Material | |||||||
Location. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
provides additional | |||||||
design freedom. | |||||||
TABLE VIa | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
19a | ABG | ABG | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced RMC | |||
G (Rc) (1L) | AL | -- | Shrinking Mandrel G' Floating in Y | (default) and IML | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | (default), the DFS | ||||||
at their BASIC relative | representing it is | ||||||
orientations! | free to translate | ||||||
as it shrinks, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
orientatiorl of both | |||||||
sides of G will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, thus | |||||||
indicating the use | |||||||
of the ALIGN tool. | |||||||
This represents the | |||||||
extension of the | |||||||
Y14.5.1 | |||||||
interpretation | |||||||
shown in |
|||||||
of the Y14.5.1M | |||||||
standard to a | |||||||
straddling Datum | |||||||
Feature with size. | |||||||
See also FIG. 19b. | |||||||
TABLE VIb | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
19b | ABG | ABD | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane ' Fixed in Z | Because G is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced RMC | |||
G (Rc) (BL) | AL | -- | Expanding Mandrel G' Fixed in Y | (default) and @ BML, | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | the DFS | ||||||
at their BASIC relative | representing it is | ||||||
orientations! | fixed relative to B | ||||||
as it shrinks, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
orientation of only | |||||||
one side of G will | |||||||
eliminate Roll. | |||||||
This represents a | |||||||
thoroughly functional | |||||||
alternative to FIG. | |||||||
19a, which the | |||||||
current standard | |||||||
could be | |||||||
"interpreted" to | |||||||
allow, but which | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifiers make | |||||||
explicit. | |||||||
TABLE VIc | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
19c | ABG | ABD (M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is |
(M) | B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced @ MMC | ||
G (Mc) (1L) | AL | ΔΔα | VMC Mandrel G' Floating in Y | and IML (default), the | |||
(+ Mobility | All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | DFS representing it | |||||
Adjust- | at their BASIC relative | is fixed at VMC but | |||||
ment) | orientations! | free to float | |||||
relative to B. | |||||||
Although this is a | |||||||
potentially natural | |||||||
dependency, it | |||||||
results in | |||||||
significant roll | |||||||
instability, and is | |||||||
probably worth | |||||||
avoiding. | |||||||
TABLE VId | ||||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | |||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | |||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments | |
19d | ABG | ABD (M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is | |
(M) | (B) | B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced @ MMC | ||
G (Mo) (BL) | AL | Δα | VMC Mandrel G' Fixed in Y | and at @ BML, | ||||
(+ Mobility | All DFSs are assumed to be frozen | the DFS representing it | ||||||
Adjust- | at their BASIC relative | is fixed in size and | ||||||
ment) | orientations! | in location | ||||||
relative to B. | ||||||||
Although similar to | ||||||||
case roll | ||||||||
instability is much | ||||||||
better controlled, | ||||||||
illustrating how | ||||||||
the Material | ||||||||
Location Modifier | ||||||||
method permits a | ||||||||
clear definition of | ||||||||
the better of two | ||||||||
possible | ||||||||
"interpretations" | ||||||||
of the sequence | ||||||||
ABG (M) allowed by | ||||||||
the current standard. | ||||||||
TABLE VIIa | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
20a | ABC | ABC | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because C is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced IML | |||
C (1L) | AL | -- | Plane C' Floating in Y | (default) the | |||
All DFSs are assumed to be | functional gage | ||||||
frozen at their BASIC relative | element representing | ||||||
orientations! | it is free to | ||||||
translate until C is | |||||||
parallel to it, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
orientation of C will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, and indicating | |||||||
the use of the ALIGN | |||||||
tool. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
makes this common | |||||||
interpretation of the | |||||||
sequence ABC | |||||||
explicit. See | |||||||
example 7.4.2 for a | |||||||
new possible | |||||||
interpretation of the | |||||||
sequence ABC. | |||||||
TABLE VIIb | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
20b | ABC | ABC (M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because C is |
B (Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced @]MML, | |||
C (ML) | AL + | Δα | Plane C' Fixed in Y at VMC | the DFS representing it | |||
Mobility | All DFSs are assumed to be | is fixed at VML | |||||
Adjust- | frozen at their BASIC relative | relative to B. | |||||
ment | orientations! | Although the | |||||
orientation of C is | |||||||
primarily responsible | |||||||
for eliminating Roll, | |||||||
its location | |||||||
determines the extent | |||||||
of the residual | |||||||
mobility. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
makes this seldom | |||||||
used but highly func- | |||||||
tional interpretation | |||||||
of ABC possible and | |||||||
explicit. Note the | |||||||
contrast with FIG. 20a. | |||||||
TABLE VIIc | |||||||
Conceptual | Mat Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
20c | AB (M) C | AB (M)C | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | This alternative is |
B (Mc) | SOX/SOY | ΔX, ΔY | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | similar to FIG. 20a, | |||
C (1L) | (+ Mobility | -- | Plane C' Floating in Y | but permits | |||
Adjust- | All DFSs are assumed to be | translational DRF | |||||
ment) | frozen at their BASIC relative | mobility in X and Y | |||||
AL | orientations! | as B departs from | |||||
MMC. Because C is | |||||||
references IML, the | |||||||
functional gage | |||||||
element representing | |||||||
it is free to | |||||||
translate with C as C | |||||||
varies in location | |||||||
relative to B, and as | |||||||
the DRF translates, | |||||||
thus insuring that C | |||||||
eliminates all Roll, | |||||||
regardless of the | |||||||
material condition of | |||||||
B. See |
|||||||
a further loosening | |||||||
of the DRF. | |||||||
TABLE VIId | |||||||
Mat | |||||||
Conceptual | Cond | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobilty | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
20d | ABD(M) | AB(M)C | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | This alternative is |
(M) | B(Mc) | SOX/SOY | ΔX, ΔY | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | similar to FIG. 20c, | ||
C(ML) | (+ Mobility | Δα | Plane C' Fixed in Y | but compounded by | |||
Adjust- | All DFSs are assumed to be | referencing B @MMC, | |||||
ment) | frozen at their BASIC relative | thus permitting the | |||||
AL | orientations! | same translational | |||||
(+ Mobility | DRF mobility in X and | ||||||
Adjust- | Y but additional | ||||||
ment) | rotational mobility | ||||||
about Z. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method makes | |||||||
this uncommon, but | |||||||
perfectly functional | |||||||
interpretation of | |||||||
AB(M)C possible and | |||||||
explicit, in contrast | |||||||
with FIG. 20c. | |||||||
Material Location Modifier Alternative II--Default: "Fixed & Floating"
In addition to certain general rules, and in the absence of specific material location modifiers, the "Fixed & Floating" default requires that all datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate roll relative to a fixed primary axis, be free to translate perpendicular to their basic axes, mid-planes or surfaces if "straddling", and be fixed at their basic locations if "non-straddling".
"Straddling" datum feature simulators with size may be fixed at their basic locations using the material location modifier BML (at basic Material Location), and those without size may be fixed at Maximum or Least Material Location using the material location modifiers MML (at Maximum Material Location) and LML (at Least Material Location) respectively, whereas "non-straddling" datum feature simulators with or without size can be made free to translate using the material location modifier IML (Independent of Material Location). TABLE VIII provides an overview of the proposed drawing symbols and their applicability.
TABLE VIII | ||||
"Fixed & Floating" Material condition/Location | ||||
Modifiers for Natural DRF Construction | ||||
Short | Long | |||
Form | Form | Full | Meaning | Applies to: |
default | RC | RMC | Regardless of Material | any feature with size |
Condition (RFS) | ||||
M | MC | MMC | at Maximum Material | any feature with size |
Condition | ||||
L | LC | LMC | at Least Material | any feature with size |
Condition | ||||
I | IL | LMC | Independent of | non-straddling features |
Material Location | with or without size | |||
B | BL | BML | at BASIC Material | straddling features |
Location | with size only | |||
M | ML | MML | at Maximum Material | straddling without |
Location | size only | |||
L | LL | LML | at Least Material | straddling features |
Location | without size only | |||
Just as in the "Floating" scenario, the modifiers (I) and (B) are added to the classical Y14.5M 1994 symbol set, and the use of the modifiers (M) and (L) is extended to apply to the location of datum features without size. However in the case of the "Fixed & Floating" default, (I) is used to mobilize non-straddling datum feature simulators and (B) to arrest straddling datum feature simulators. There is no danger of confusion between (M) used for MMC and (M) used for MML, or between (L) used for LMC and (L) used for LML, because the former apply only to features with size, and the latter only to features without size.
Rules of Material Location "Fixed & Floating" Default:
1. All datum feature simulators representing Datum Targets are fixed at their BASIC locations relative to previously established Datums.
2. All datum feature simulators which do not serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis are fixed at their BASIC locations relative to previously established Datums.
3. All straddling datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis are free to float in a direction perpendicular to their basic axes, mid-planes or surfaces unless associated with the material location modifiers (B), (M) or (L) used as set forth in the table above.
4. All Non-straddling datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis are fixed at their basic locations unless associated with the material location modifiers (I), (M) or (L) used as set forth in the table above.
Examples of "Fixed and Floating" Default Alternative
To demonstrate the implications of the "Fixed and Floating" default alternative, four different scenarios are presented as illustrated in
1.
These figures illustrate the effects on DRF construction of a rotation of datum feature about a vertical axis through its midpoint by -15°C, 0°C, and +15°C.
In the default scenario, by saying nothing, it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage datum feature D be free to expand to consume all the space inside D, but fixed at BML, thus making its location responsible for eliminating roll. This alternative creates a completely static DRF, is in keeping with the common "shop floor interpretation" of the "hockey puck" conundrum, and is illustrated in
As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
2.
These figures illustrate the effects on DRF construction of a shift in the Y location of datum feature E relative to datum feature B from 1.240 to 1.250 to 1.260.
In the "Fixed & Floating" default scenario, by saying nothing (the invisible symbol for IML), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage E be fixed at its basic location, thus making the location of E responsible for eliminating roll, regardless of its orientation. This alternative creates a static DRF under all circumstances by pivoting E about B until it runs up against E', and is shown in
Adding the modifier (I) for IML to datum feature E requires the DFS intended to engage E to be free to translate until stability is achieved, thus making the orientation of E responsible for eliminating roll, independent of the location of E. This alternative creates a static DRF to the extent E is not convex (a "rocker"), and is shown in
Adding a stand-alone (M) for @MML, or (L) for @LML to datum feature E produces an effect similar to that of the default @BML, except in these cases datum feature E is free to pivot until it runs up against DFS E' here fixed at the feature's maximum or least Virtual Material Location (VML) as illustrated in
3.
These figures illustrate the effect on DRF construction of a change in the width of datum feature C from 4.010 to 4.000 to 3.990 with a commensurate shift in the center plane from -0.005 to 0.000 to +0.005.
In the "Fixed & Floating" default scenario, by saying nothing (the invisible symbols for IML and RMC), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage datum feature G be free to translate and contract to consume all the space outside G, thus making the orientation of the entire feature responsible for eliminating roll. This alternative creates a static DRF to the extent G is not wedge- or barrel-shaped, and is shown in
As shown in
As shown in
As shown in
These examples demonstrate a number of new DRF alternatives which the addition of material location modifiers make available.
4.
These figures illustrate the effects on DRF construction of a shift in the location of datum feature C relative to B from 1.990 to 2.000 to 2.010.
In the "Fixed & Floating" default scenario, by saying nothing (the invisible symbol for IML), it is automatically stipulated that the DFS intended to engage datum feature C be free to translate until stability is achieved, thus making the orientation of C responsible for eliminating roll, independent of its location. This is the standard interpretation of this scenario, and leads to a static DRF to the extent C is not convex (a "rocker"). It is illustrated in
As shown in
In summary,
All examples use the following abbreviations:
The symbols used in the column labeled "Conceptual DRF Construction Commands" are to be understood as follows: OR=ORIENT, AL=ALIGN, PI=PIVOT, SOX, SOY and SOZ=SET ORIGIN in X, Y, and Z respectively.
The symbols used in the column labeled "Material Condition Dependent Mobility" are to be understood as follows: ΔX, ΔY, ΔZ stand for residual Material Condition and Material Location induced translational mobility along DRF X, Y and Z, axes respectively, whereas Δa stands for minimal and ΔΔa for significant residual roll mobility.
Datum feature simulators bear the same labels as their associated datum features, but with the addition of an apostrophe. The labels are to be read as: datum feature A and datum feature simulator A'.
TABLE IXa | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
21a | ABD | ABD | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D lacks any |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | modifiers, the | |||
D(Rc) (BL) | PI | -- | Expanding Mandrel D' Fixed in Y | functional gage | |||
All functional gage components | component | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | representing it is | ||||||
their BASIC relative | free to expand but | ||||||
orientations! | fixed in location, | ||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
location of D will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, indicating the | |||||||
use of the PIVOT | |||||||
tool. This | |||||||
represents the common | |||||||
interpretation of | |||||||
ABD. | |||||||
TABLE IXb | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
21b | ABD | ABD(I) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced RMC and | |||
E(IL) | AL | -- | Plane, Fixed in Y at BML | IML, the functional | |||
All functional gage components | gage component | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | representing it is | ||||||
their BASIC relative | free to float as it | ||||||
orientations! | expands, insuring | ||||||
that the orientation | |||||||
of D will serve to | |||||||
eliminate Roll, | |||||||
indicating the use of | |||||||
the ALIGN tool. This | |||||||
represents the | |||||||
Y14.5.1 | |||||||
interpretation of ABD | |||||||
shown in |
|||||||
the Y14.5.1.M 1994 | |||||||
standard and | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Condition | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
clearly | |||||||
differentiates | |||||||
between this | |||||||
alternative and the | |||||||
one shown in FIG. | |||||||
21a. | |||||||
TABLE IXc | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
21c | ABD(M) | ABD(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced @MMC and | |||
D(Mc) (BL) | PI | Δα | VMC Mandrel, Fixed in Y | @BML, the functional | |||
(+ Mobil- | All functional gage components | gage element | |||||
ity | are assumed to be frozen at | representing it is | |||||
Adjust- | their BASIC relative | fixed in size (VMC) | |||||
ment) | orientations! | and in location | |||||
relative to B, | |||||||
insuring that the | |||||||
location of D will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, thus indicating | |||||||
the use of the PIVOT | |||||||
tool. In this case D | |||||||
is a reliable roll | |||||||
controlling feature, | |||||||
allowing only a small | |||||||
degree of rotational | |||||||
mobility as D departs | |||||||
from MMC. | |||||||
TABLE IXd | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
21d | ABD(M) | ABD(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because D is |
(I) | B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced @MMC and | ||
D(Mc) (IL) | AL(?) | ΔΔα | VMC Mandrel, Floating in Y | IML, the functional | |||
PI(?) | All functional gage components | gage element | |||||
(+ Mobil- | are assumed to be frozen at | representing it will | |||||
ity | their BASIC relative | be at VMC and free to | |||||
Adjust- | orientations! | float in Y, thus | |||||
ment) | providing no clear | ||||||
cut means for | |||||||
eliminating Roll. | |||||||
Although this | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
"natural DRF | |||||||
construction" method | |||||||
defines a completely | |||||||
unambiguous | |||||||
alternative, this | |||||||
happens to be one | |||||||
worth avoiding. | |||||||
TABLE Xa | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
22a | ABE | ABE | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because E is |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | referenced at BML | |||
E(IL) | PI | -- | Plane E' Floating in Y | (default), the | |||
All functional gage components | functional gage | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | element representing | ||||||
their BASIC relative | it is fixed in Y, | ||||||
orientations! | insuring that the | ||||||
location of E will | |||||||
serve to eliminate | |||||||
Roll, thus indicating | |||||||
the use of the PIVOT | |||||||
tool. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
clearly defines the | |||||||
first alternative of | |||||||
the two possible | |||||||
interpretations of | |||||||
the common sequence | |||||||
ABE. See also FIG. | |||||||
22b. | |||||||
TABLE Xb | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
22b | ABE | ABE(I) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because E is |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | explicitly referenced | |||
E(IL) | AL | -- | Plane, Fixed in Y at BML | IML, the functional | |||
All functional gage components | gage element | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | representing it is | ||||||
their BASIC relative | to translate | ||||||
orientations! | until E is parallel | ||||||
to it, insuring that | |||||||
the direction of E | |||||||
will serve to | |||||||
eliminate Roll, thus | |||||||
indicating the use of | |||||||
the ALIGN tool. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method | |||||||
clearly defines the | |||||||
second alternative of | |||||||
the two possible | |||||||
interpretations of | |||||||
the common sequence | |||||||
ABE. See also FIG. | |||||||
22a. | |||||||
22c | ABE | ABE(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | As in |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | location of E serves | |||
E(ML) | PI | -- | Plane E' Fixed in Y at MML | to eliminate Roll, | |||
All functional gage components | again indicating the | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | PIVOT tool, however | ||||||
their BASIC relative | in this case the | ||||||
orientations! | functional gage | ||||||
component | |||||||
representing it is | |||||||
explicitly located at | |||||||
Maximum Material | |||||||
Location, providing a | |||||||
new alternative for | |||||||
DRF construction. | |||||||
TABLE Xc | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
22d | ABE | ABE(L) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plate A' Fixed in Z | As in |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in XY | location of E serves | |||
E(LL) | PI | -- | Plane E' Fixed in Y at LML | to eliminate Roll, | |||
All functional gage components | again indicating the | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | PIVOT tool, however | ||||||
their BASIC relative | in this case the | ||||||
orientations! | functional gage | ||||||
component | |||||||
representing it is | |||||||
explicitly located at | |||||||
Least Material | |||||||
Location, providing a | |||||||
new alternative for | |||||||
DRF construction. | |||||||
TABLE XIa | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
23a | ABG | ABG | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is referenced |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | RMC (default) and IML | |||
G(Rc) (IL) | AL | -- | XY | (default), the | |||
Shrinking Mandrel G' Floating | functional gage | ||||||
in Y | component representing | ||||||
All functional gage components | it is free to translate | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | as it shrinks, insuring | ||||||
their BASIC relative | that the orientation of | ||||||
orientations! | both sides of G will | ||||||
serve to eliminate Roll, | |||||||
thus indicating the use | |||||||
of the ALIGN tool. This | |||||||
represents the extension | |||||||
of the Y14.5.1 | |||||||
interpretation shown in | |||||||
standard to a straddling | |||||||
Datum Feature with size. | |||||||
See also |
|||||||
23b | ABG | ABG(B) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is referenced |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | RMC (default) and @BML, | |||
G(RC)(BL) | AL | -- | XY | the functional gage | |||
Shrinking Mandrel G' Fixed in | component representing | ||||||
Y | it is fixed relative to | ||||||
All functional gage components | B as it shrinks, | ||||||
are assumed to be frozen at | insuring that the | ||||||
their BASIC relative | orientation of only one | ||||||
orientations! | side of G will eliminate | ||||||
Roll. This represents a | |||||||
thoroughly functional | |||||||
alternative to FIG. 23a, | |||||||
which the current | |||||||
standard could be | |||||||
"interpreted" to allow, | |||||||
but which Material | |||||||
Location Modifiers make | |||||||
explicit. | |||||||
TABLE XIb | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Feature Simulators | Comments |
23c | ABG(M) | ABG(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is referenced |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | @MMC and IML (default), | |||
G(Mc)(IL) | (+ Mobil- | ΔΔα | XY | the functional gage | |||
ity | VMC Mandrel G' Floating in Y | component representing | |||||
Adjust- | All functional gage components | it is fixed at VMC but | |||||
ment) | are assumed to be frozen at | free to float relative | |||||
their BASIC relative | to B. Although this is | ||||||
orientations! | a potentially natural | ||||||
functional dependency, | |||||||
it results in | |||||||
significant roll | |||||||
instability, and is | |||||||
probably worth avoiding. | |||||||
23d | ABG(M) | ABG(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because G is referenced |
(B) | B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | @MMC and @BML, the | ||
G(Mc)(BL) | AL | Δα | XY | functional gage | |||
(+ Mobil- | VMC Mandrel G' Fixed in Y | component representing | |||||
ity | All functional gage components | it is fixed in size and | |||||
Adjust- | are assumed to be frozen at | in location relative to | |||||
ment) | their BASIC relative | B. Although similar to | |||||
orientations! | |||||||
roll instability is much | |||||||
better controlled, | |||||||
illustrating how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method permits | |||||||
a clear definition of | |||||||
the better of two | |||||||
possible | |||||||
"interpretations" of the | |||||||
sequence ABG(M) allowed | |||||||
by the current standard. | |||||||
TABLE XIIa | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Features Simulators | Comments |
24a | ABC | ABC | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because C is referenced |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | IML (default), the | |||
C(IL) | AL | -- | XY | functional gage element | |||
Plane C' Floating in Y | representing it is free | ||||||
All functional gage | to translate until C is | ||||||
components are assumed to be | parallel to it, insuring | ||||||
frozen at their BASIC | that the orientation of | ||||||
relative orientations! | C will serve to | ||||||
eliminate Roll, and | |||||||
indicating the use of | |||||||
the ALIGN tool. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method makes | |||||||
this common | |||||||
interpretation of the | |||||||
sequence ABC explicit | |||||||
See |
|||||||
possible interpretation | |||||||
of the sequence ABC. | |||||||
TABLE XIIb | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Features Simulators | Comments |
24b | ABC | ABC(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | Because C is referenced |
B(Rc) | SOX/SOY | -- | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | @MML, the functional | |||
C(ML) | AL | Δα | XY | gage component | |||
(+ Mobil- | Plane C' Fixed in Y at VMC | representing it is fixed | |||||
ity | All functional gage | at VML relative to B. | |||||
Adjust- | components are assumed to be | Although the orientation | |||||
ment) | frozen at their BASIC | of C is primarily | |||||
relative orientations! | responsible for | ||||||
eliminating Roll, its | |||||||
location determines the | |||||||
extent of the residual | |||||||
mobility. This | |||||||
illustrates how the | |||||||
Material Location | |||||||
Modifier method makes | |||||||
this seldom used but | |||||||
highly functional | |||||||
interpretation of ABC | |||||||
possible and explicit. | |||||||
Note the contrast with | |||||||
FIG. 24a. | |||||||
TABLE XIIc | |||||||
Conceptual | Matl. Cond. | ||||||
FIG. | FCF Def | DRF Constr | Depend | ||||
No. | Current | Proposed | Complete | Commands | Mobility | Datum Features Simulators | Comments |
24c | AB(M)C | AB(M)C | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | This alternative is |
B(Mc) | SOX,SOY | ΔX, ΔY | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | similar to |
|||
C(IL) | AL | XY | permits translational | ||||
(+ Mobil- | Plane C' Floating in Y | DRF mobility in X and Y | |||||
ity | All functional gage | as B departs from MMC. | |||||
Adjust- | components are assumed to be | Because C is referenced | |||||
ment) | frozen at their BASIC | IML, the functional gage | |||||
relative orientations! | element representing it | ||||||
is free to translate | |||||||
with C as C varies in | |||||||
location relative to B, | |||||||
and as the DRF | |||||||
translates, thus | |||||||
insuring that C | |||||||
eliminates all Roll, | |||||||
regardless of the | |||||||
material condition of B. | |||||||
See |
|||||||
further loosening of the | |||||||
DRF. | |||||||
24d | AB(M)C | AB(M) | A | OR/SOZ | -- | Plane A' Fixed in Z | This alternative is |
C(M) | B(Mc) | SOX/SOY | ΔX, ΔY | Expanding Mandrel B' Fixed in | similar to |
||
C(ML) | (+ Mobil- | Δα | XY | compounded by | |||
ity | Plane C' Fixed in Y | referencing B @MMC, thus | |||||
Adjust- | All functional gage | permitting the same | |||||
ment) | components are assumed to be | translational DRF | |||||
AL | frozen at their BASIC | mobility in X and Y but | |||||
(+ Mobil- | relative orientations! | additional rotational | |||||
ity | mobility about Z. This | ||||||
Adjust- | illustrates how the | ||||||
ment) | Material Location | ||||||
Modifier method makes | |||||||
this uncommon, but | |||||||
perfectly functional | |||||||
interpretation of AB(M)C | |||||||
possible and explicit, | |||||||
in contrast with FIG. | |||||||
24c. | |||||||
Material Location Modifier Alternative III--Default: "Fixed"
In addition to certain general rules, and in the absence of specific material location modifiers, the "Fixed" default requires that all datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate roll relative to a fixed primary axis be fixed, at their basic locations, except those representing straddling Datum Features without size, which shall be fixed at MML (at Maximum Material Location).
Thus, the material location modifiers BML (at BASIC Material Location) and, in the case of straddling datum features without size, MML (at Maximum Material Location) are implied in the absence of other modifiers. Furthermore, any datum feature simulator may be made free to translate in a direction perpendicular to its basic axis, mid-plane or surface using the material location modifier IML (Independent of Material Location).
Furthermore any datum feature simulator representing a datum feature without size may be fixed at Least or Maximum Material Location using the material location modifiers LML (at Least Material Location) and MML (at Maximum Material Location) respectively. TABLE XIII provides an overview of the proposed drawing symbols and their applicability.
TABLE XIII | ||||
"Fixed" Material condition/Location Modifiers for Natural DRF Construction | ||||
Short Form | Long Form | Full | Meaning | Applies to: |
default | Rc | RMC | Regardless of Material Condition (RFS) | any feature with size |
M | Mc | MMC | at Maximum Material Condition | any feature with size |
L | Lc | LMC | at Least Material Condition | any feature with size |
I | IL | IML | Independent of Material Location | any feature |
default | BL | BML | at BASIC Material Location | any feature except |
straddling features | ||||
w/o size | ||||
M | ML | MML | at Maximum Material Location | straddling and non- |
straddling features | ||||
w/o size | ||||
L | LL | LML | at Least Material Location | straddling and non- |
straddling features | ||||
w/o size | ||||
Just as in the "Floating" and "Fixed & Floating" scenarios, the modifiers (I) and (B) are added to the classical Y14.5M 1994 symbol set, and the use of the modifiers (M) and (L) is extended to apply to the location of datum features without size. However in the case of the "Fixed" default, (B) is always implied, except in the case of straddling datum features without size, when (M) is implied, (I) can be used to mobilize any datum feature simulator, and (M) and (L) can be used to fix any datum feature without size at either MML or LML respectively. Just as in the previous cases, there is no danger of confusion between (M) used for MMC and (M) used for MML, or between (L) used for LMC and (L) used for LML, because the former apply only to features with size, and the latter only to features without size.
Rules of Material Location ("Fixed" Default):
1. All datum feature simulators representing Datum Targets are fixed at their BASIC locations relative to previously established Datums.
2. All datum feature simulators which do not serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis are fixed at their BASIC locations relative to previously established Datums.
3. All datum feature simulators which serve to eliminate Roll about a previously fixed primary DRF axis are fixed at Basic Material Location (BML) except those representing straddling datum features without size, which are fixed at Maximum Material Location (MML), unless associated with the material location modifiers (I), (M) or (L) used as set forth in the table above.
Material Location Modifier Alternative IV--Default "None"
A fourth alternative is to specify Material Location Modifiers explicitly at all times. The examples in this case follow directly from those provided for the other three alternatives.
Computer Implementation
The system 200 can be a Computer Aided Design (CAD) system which is specifically designed for processing information relating to machine part design and which constructs a DRF and/or FCF during the course of its operation, or can be any other type of apparatus such as machine for manufacturing or measuring machine parts which constructs a DRF during the course of its operation.
The system 200 includes a random access memory (RAM) 202 in which a software program 204 including instructions or code which implement the functionality of the system 200 is stored, and a processor 206 for executing the program 204. The system 200 further includes a visual display unit or monitor 208 for providing a graphic user interface, a read-only memory (ROM) 210 for storing firmware, and an input-output (I/O) unit 212 for connection to a printer, plotter, etc.
The system 200 further includes a mass data storage device 214 which can be any combination of suitable elements such as a fixed (hard) magnetic disk drive, a removable (floppy) magnetic disk drive, an optical (CD-ROM) drive, etc., and at least one input device 216 such as a keyboard, mouse, digitizer tablet, etc.
A specification of a part, comprising datum features including a sequence in which the datum features are to be processed, and a material location modifier for a datum feature which is intended to eliminate roll in the DRF, the material location modifier designating whether said datum feature should be used to eliminate roll using said datum feature's orientation or location, is input to the system 200. This can be accomplished using the input device (keyboard) 216, or alternatively the specification can be read from a floppy disk or other medium using the data storage device 214. The program, is then executed to process the specification.
The program 204 will normally be stored on a data storage medium such as a magnetic disk, optical disk (CD-ROM), etc. which is removably inserted into the data storage device 214. The program 204 is loaded from the medium into the RAM 202, and executed using the processor 206. The present invention further includes such a computer data storage medium on which a program which implements the functionality of the invention is stored.
It will be noted that the RAM 202 itself is such a data storage medium within the scope of the invention. As yet another alternative, the program 204 can be stored in the ROM 210, which is typically an integrated circuit chip and also constitutes a data storage medium in accordance with the invention.
The system 200 can be used by the designer of a machine part or object to construct a formal drawing including a Feature Control Frame with material location modifiers in accordance with either of the four alternative scenarios described above. Preferably, the program 204 will be designed such that. only the default material location modifier and appropriate alternative material location modifiers for a datum feature being considered will be displayed in a menu, prompt, etc. on the monitor 208 for selection by a user.
Although the set of material location modifiers can include material location modifiers which are inappropriate for a particular datum feature, the program will automatically not display these inappropriate alternatives, thereby ensuring that an erroneous formal drawing is not produced. As another feature, the program can display informative text, icons, etc. relating to the displayed material condition modifiers.
The program 204 is preferably designed to construct a DRF in accordance with the flowchart illustrated in
(a) Identify a next datum feature in the sequence.
(b) Determine if pitch and yaw have already been eliminated.
(c) If pitch and yaw have not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature is capable of eliminating pitch and yaw, apply an ORIENT tool to the next datum feature to eliminate pitch and yaw, and if datum feature is referenced at MMC or LMC, set DRF Pitch and Yaw Mobility Flag.
(d) Determine if roll has been eliminated.
(e) If roll has not been eliminated, and if the primary DRF axis is not fixed, and if the datum feature has a unit vector, apply an ALIGN tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's orientation.
(e") If roll has not been eliminated, and if the primary DRF axis is fixed, and if the next datum feature is a sphere or is axial and has an axis parallel to the primary axis, apply a PIVOT tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's orientation, and if the datum feature is referenced at MMC or LMC set the DRF Roll Mobility Flag.
(f) If roll has not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature has size and straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, apply an ALIGN tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's orientation, and if the datum feature is referenced at MMC or LMC set the DRF Roll Mobility Flag.
(f') If roll has not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature does not have size and straddles a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, apply an ALIGN tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's orientation, and if the datum feature is referenced at MMC or LMC set the DRF Roll Mobility Flag.
(f") If roll has not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, and if the next datum feature has size and is associated with the material location modifier Independent of Material Location (IML), apply an ALIGN tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the datum feature's orientation.
(g) If roll has not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, and if the next datum feature has size and is associated with a material location modifier Basic Material Location (BML), apply a PIVOT tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's location.
(g') If roll has not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, and if the next datum feature does not have size and is associated with a material location modifier Independent of Material Location (IML), apply an ALIGN tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's orientation.
(g") If roll has not been eliminated, and if the next datum feature does not straddle a previously fixed primary axis of the DRF, and if the next datum feature does not have size and is associated with a material location modifier Basic Material Location (BML), Maximum Material Location (MML) or Least Material Location (LML), apply a PIVOT tool to the next datum feature to eliminate roll using the next datum feature's location.
(h) Determine if all degrees of translational freedom have been eliminated;
(i) If all degrees of translational freedom have not been eliminated, apply a SET ORIGIN tool to the next datum feature to eliminate all permissible and possible degrees of translational freedom, and if the datum feature is referenced at MMC or LMC set the DRF Translation Mobility Flag.
(j) Determine if all degrees of freedom have been eliminated.
(k) If all degrees of freedom have not been eliminated and more datum features exist, repeat steps (a) to (j), otherwise terminate processing.
Applications
A method and apparatus for automatically constructing a DRF and/or FCF can be incorporated into numerous applications including, but not limited to, the following.
Machine Part Design
The material location modifier (MLM) method of the present invention provides the means for creating drawings in which the design intent concerning the effect of roll eliminating datum features relative to fixed primary DRF axes is fully explicit.
This applies to hand made drawings as well as to those created using Computer Aided Design (CAD) systems.
Due to the complexity of constructing Feature Control Frames (FCF) and of selecting proper Material Condition and Material Location Modifiers, it is of interest to provide expert systems support for the process. The MLM method and apparatus permit a CAD system to recognize, during FCF construction, whether a roll eliminating Datum Feature is straddling or non-straddling, whether it has size or does not, and therefore to suggest the permissible Material Location. Modifier alternatives and forecast their effect.
There is growing interest in the CAD environment to undertake "computer assisted tolerance analysis". An important part of any such effort has to do with the construction of the DRFs defined by the various Feature Control Frames (FCF) associated with features in a computer model. The MLM method and apparatus permit a CAD system to automatically construct the DRF defined by the Datum Features and datum feature modifiers stipulated in a FCF, and thereby (1) determine whether said DRF can actually be constructed and (2), based on the permissible variations of the datum features, determine the extent to which said DRF is stable enough to provide the desired control of the features referenced to it.
Machine Part Manufacturing
The MLM method for defining DRFs provides means to unambiguously specify (1) the design of the fixtures which hold parts in Machine Tools (MT) during the manufacturing process, (2) the "set-up" of MTs prior to material removal; and (3) the in-process verification of part geometry in emulation of a Coordinate Measuring Machine (CMM).
Most commonly, MT "set-up" involves setting linear and rotary MT axis origins by indicating or probing datum features on each successive part, or by indicating or probing the datum feature simulators on the machining fixture. In advanced computer controlled 5 axis MTs, the possibility exists for coarsely securing parts in the machine and then probing their datum features in emulation of a CMM to determine the relevant DRFs for machine path control. The MLM method and attendant automatic DRF construction process thus permit further automation of the manufacturing process.
Machine Part Inspection/Functional Gage Design and Use
The MLM method for defining DRFs provides means to unambiguously specify the design of certain portions of the functional gages used to assess machine part geometry. In particular, the method permits a clear decision as to whether a DFS intended to eliminate roll about a primary axis defining component is to be fixed in space relative to said component or free to translate in a direction perpendicular to the axis, center plane or surface of the roll eliminating component.
Machine Part Inspection/Coordinate Measuring Machine Use
Coordinate Measuring Machines (CMM) simulate functional gages (1) by constructing DRFs from point clouds collected on stipulated Datum Features, and (2) by analyzing the geometry of Considered Features from point clouds collected on said Considered Features.
The process of CMM based DRF construction is currently computer assisted by mathematical tools fulfilling the operations of the ORIENT, ALIGN, PIVOT, SET ORIGIN, TRANSLATE and ROTATE tools as used by the present invention, but whose selection and application remain in the hands of the operator/programmer. The difficulty of comprehending the DRFs defined by particular sets of datum features and datum feature modifiers combined with the human dependence of the current DRF construction process lead to frequent errors in CMM based DRF construction.
The MLM method for automatic DRF construction permits CMM programmers/operators to measure and enter datum features and their material condition and material location modifiers into the computer for completely automatic implementation. The effect is to insure rigorously correct DRF construction on a repetitive basis and to greatly reduce processing time by eliminating the deliberation phase now inherent in the process.
The present invention fulfills the need which has existed heretofore in the prior art by providing a computer implemented method for automatically and unambiguously constructing a Datum Reference Frame (DRF) for a machine part.
Various modifications will become possible for those skilled in the art after receiving the teachings of the present disclosure without departing from the scope thereof.
Patent | Priority | Assignee | Title |
6661930, | Apr 25 2000 | General Electric Company | Method for nesting a computer model of a part with a computer model of a fixture |
6662071, | Apr 25 2000 | General Electric Company | Method of manufacturing precision parts with non-precision fixtures |
6826510, | Nov 14 2002 | General Electric Company | Method, system and computer product for performing geometric dimension and tolerance stack-up analysis |
6879933, | Nov 16 2001 | FARO TECHNOLOGIES, INC | Method and system for assisting a user taking measurements using a coordinate measurement machine |
6922606, | Nov 19 1999 | SIEMENS INDUSTRY, INC | Apparatus and method for smooth cornering in a motion control system |
6978220, | Mar 02 2004 | The Boeing Company | Combined feature dimensional parameter analysis |
7194387, | Sep 30 2005 | Intel Corporation | Apparatus and method for determining the minimum zone for an array of features with a true position tolerance |
7248992, | Mar 02 2004 | The Boeing Company | Combined feature dimensional parameter analysis |
7289937, | Nov 14 2002 | General Electric Company | Method and apparatus for machine vector loop extraction |
7571079, | Jan 26 2005 | Dassault Systemes SolidWorks Corporation | Aware and active features for computer-aided design systems |
7660697, | Aug 12 2005 | Fujitsu Limited | Apparatus and method for calculating size tolerance, and computer-readable recording medium in which program for calculating size tolerance is stored |
7894930, | Feb 07 2008 | HEXAGON METROLOGY, INC ; HEXAGON TECHNOLOGY CENTER GMBH | Method and device for composite machining based on tool-path pattern types with tool axis orientation rules |
8355813, | Sep 05 2008 | Mori Seiki Co., Ltd. | Machining status monitoring method and machining status monitoring apparatus |
8392151, | Sep 28 2005 | MATHWORKS, INC ,THE | Preview of an object in graphical modeling environments |
8428768, | Feb 07 2008 | HEXAGON METROLOGY, INC ; HEXAGON TECHNOLOGY CENTER GMBH | Method and device for composite machining based on tool-path pattern types with tool axis orientation rules |
8862442, | Sep 28 2005 | The MathWorks, Inc. | Preview of an object in graphical modeling environments |
8923999, | Sep 07 2011 | Siemens Industry Software Inc | Volumetric cut planning |
9411927, | Oct 09 2012 | The Boeing Company | Float remaining volume identification |
Patent | Priority | Assignee | Title |
4296474, | Sep 06 1977 | Deere & Company | Inspection system and apparatus therefor |
4754417, | Feb 29 1984 | CUMMINS ENGINE IP, INC | Computer implemented go/no go gauging system |
4918627, | Aug 04 1986 | FMC Corporation | Computer integrated gaging system |
5208763, | Sep 14 1990 | New York University | Method and apparatus for determining position and orientation of mechanical objects |
5465221, | Dec 30 1993 | United States Air Force | Automated process planning for quality control inspection |
5586052, | Apr 27 1993 | SIEMENS PRODUCT LIFECYCLE MANAGEMENT SOFTWARE INC | Rule based apparatus and method for evaluating an engineering design for correctness and completeness |
5949693, | Sep 06 1996 | Computer aided design (CAD) system for automatically constructing datum reference frame (DRF) and feature control frame (FCF) for machine part |
Executed on | Assignor | Assignee | Conveyance | Frame | Reel | Doc |
Date | Maintenance Fee Events |
Aug 02 2006 | REM: Maintenance Fee Reminder Mailed. |
Jan 14 2007 | EXP: Patent Expired for Failure to Pay Maintenance Fees. |
Date | Maintenance Schedule |
Jan 14 2006 | 4 years fee payment window open |
Jul 14 2006 | 6 months grace period start (w surcharge) |
Jan 14 2007 | patent expiry (for year 4) |
Jan 14 2009 | 2 years to revive unintentionally abandoned end. (for year 4) |
Jan 14 2010 | 8 years fee payment window open |
Jul 14 2010 | 6 months grace period start (w surcharge) |
Jan 14 2011 | patent expiry (for year 8) |
Jan 14 2013 | 2 years to revive unintentionally abandoned end. (for year 8) |
Jan 14 2014 | 12 years fee payment window open |
Jul 14 2014 | 6 months grace period start (w surcharge) |
Jan 14 2015 | patent expiry (for year 12) |
Jan 14 2017 | 2 years to revive unintentionally abandoned end. (for year 12) |