A component for a plasma arc torch includes a body portion, a tapered surface on the body portion, the tapered surface including a compressible member that provides a disengagement force relative to the body portion, and an axially disposed surface on the body portion for coupling a mating surface on an adjacent structure of the torch. The component can be a nozzle and/or an electrode.

Patent
   RE49153
Priority
Jan 23 2007
Filed
Oct 02 2020
Issued
Jul 26 2022
Expiry
Jan 23 2027
Assg.orig
Entity
Large
0
16
currently ok
11. A method for aligning a first component in a plasma torch assembly, the first component having an axial stop and a tapered surface for engaging a compressible member, the first component being maintained in contact in the plasma torch assembly by a retaining cap, wherein the first component is a torch body, the method comprising:
slideably engaging the axial stop of the first component to a second component of the plasma torch assembly to position the second component relative to the first component in an axial direction; and
biasing the compressible member against the tapered surface of the first component to radially align the first component to the second component, wherein the components are dimensioned such that, after the retaining cap is removed, the components freely disengage, without the use of tools, after an operation of the plasma torch assembly.
12. A method for aligning a first component and a second component of a plasma torch assembly, having a compressible member disposed between the two components and a retaining cap for maintaining the first and second components in contact in the plasma torch assembly, the method comprising:
axially aligning the first component to the second component by a rigid primary datum;
radially aligning the first component to the second component by a flexible secondary datum, such that the compressible member radially aligns the first component and the second component and axially biases the first component in an unassembled direction relative to the second component, the first component dimensioned such that the bias in the unassembled direction enables the first component to freely disengage from the plasma torch assembly, after the retaining cap is removed, without the use of tools, after an operation of the plasma torch assembly.
15. A method for engagement of a replaceable consumable component within a plasma arc torch having a first component and a retaining cap, the first component including a torch body having a tapered surface and an axially disposed surface, the retaining cap coupling the replaceable consumable component and the first component within the plasma torch, the method comprising:
providing a compressible member that, when biased, provides an axial disengagement force, wherein the tapered surface on the first component is dimensioned to engage the compressible member;
slideably engaging the first component with the replaceable consumable component, wherein the compressible member is disposed between the tapered surface of the first component and a surface of the replaceable consumable component; and
biasing the compressible member between the tapered surface of the first component and the surface of the replaceable consumable component to establish the axial disengagement force relative to the replaceable consumable component such that, when the retaining cap is removed, the axial disengagement force causes the replaceable consumable component to freely disengage from the plasma arc torch without the use of tools.
1. A method for engagement of a replaceable consumable component with a first component in a plasma arc torch, the replaceable consumable component and the first component being maintained in contact in the plasma torch by a retaining cap, wherein the first component is a torch body having a tapered surface and an axially disposed surface on a body portion of the first component, the method comprising:
providing a compressible member, wherein the tapered surface on the body portion of the first component is dimensioned to engage the compressible member;
slideably engaging the first component with the replaceable consumable component, the replaceable consumable component including a body and a mating surface for engaging the axially disposed surface of the first component, the compressible member disposed between the tapered surface of the first component and a second surface of the replaceable consumable component; and
biasing the compressible member between the tapered surface of the first component and the second surface of the replaceable consumable component to establish a disengagement force relative to the body portion of the first component such that, after the retaining cap is removed, the replaceable consumable component freely disengages from the plasma arc torch without the use of tools after an operation of the torch.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the replaceable consumable component is one of a nozzle, a shield, a swirl ring, or an electrode, or a portion of a body of the plasma arc torch.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein the compressible member radially aligns the body portion with a central axis of the torch.
4. The method of claim 1, wherein the tapered surface on the body portion has a clearance in the range of 0.00001 to 0.002 inches (0.000254 to 0.0508 mm) with respect to the surface of the replaceable consumable component.
5. The method of claim 1, wherein the compressible member provides a seal between the body portion and the replaceable consumable component.
6. The method of claim 1, wherein the compressible member is an O-ring.
7. The method of claim 1, wherein the tapered surface includes a feature for receiving the compressible member.
8. The method of claim 7, wherein the feature on the tapered surface is a recess defined by the body portion.
9. The method of claim 1, wherein the axially disposed surface of the first component and the mating surface of the replaceable consumable component are electrically coupled.
10. The method of claim 1, wherein the axially disposed surface axially aligns the body portion in an axial position relative to the mating surface of the replaceable consumable component.
13. The method of claim 1 wherein the biasing of the compressible member establishes a compression vector having both an axial component and a radial component, the radial component of the compression vector configured to radially align the consumable component within the body of the torch, and the axial component of the compression vector configured to provide the disengagement force.
14. The method of claim 12 wherein the bias in the unassembled direction enables the first component to freely disengage relative to the second component, after the retaining cap is removed, without the use of tools following an operation of the plasma torch assembly.
16. The method of claim 15 further comprising providing a compressible member that, when biased, provides a radial disengagement force that serves to align the replaceable consumable component and the first component radially.
17. The method of claim 15 wherein the replaceable consumable component is one of a nozzle, a shield, a swirl ring, or an electrode, or a portion of a body of the plasma arc torch.

Plasma arc torches are widely used in the cutting, welding, and heat treating of metallic materials. A plasma arc torch generally includes a cathode block with an electrode mounted therein, a nozzle with a central exit orifice mounted within a torch body, electrical connections, passages for cooling and arc control fluids, a swirl ring to control fluid flow patterns in the plasma chamber formed between the electrode and nozzle, and a power supply. Sustaining a plasma arc causes the electrode, nozzle, swirl ring, and shield to wear requiring routine replacement; as such, the component parts are known as “consumables”.

Gas cooled plasma cutting torches exist which allow the consumable component parts to be changed without requiring tools. However, these gas cooled torches commonly use the same fluid (e.g. air) to support the cutting process and to cool the torch. Because only a single gas is used in such torches, there is less of a need to segregate the different gases between the various torch components (through the use of seals, o-rings, and the like). As a result of generally looser alignment of the components, gas cooled torches tend to be generally easy to disassemble.

Liquid cooled torches, by comparison, require tight seals for segregating the different fluids/gases between the torch components. While these seals effectively control the fluid/gas flow between the different torch components, they also tend to hold the torch components tightly together. As a result, liquid cooled plasma cutting torches commonly require a specially designed tool to install and remove each consumable component part. For example, a specially designed tool is needed to install and remove the electrode, while another specially designed tool is needed to install and remove the nozzle, etc.

Various factors facilitate the need for these specially designed tools. One factor includes the size of the consumable component part. For example, many consumable component parts have outside diameters less than 1 inch (2.54 cm) in size, making it difficult to generate enough torque to install and remove the consumable component parts by hand. Another factor includes precision alignment of the consumable component parts which requires small clearances between the mating diameters of the parts and the torch body. For example, part designs with tight radial clearances frequently do not freely mate with the torch body. Yet another factor includes incorporating seals, such as O-ring seals, in the consumable component part designs for containing and separating the liquid coolant and the process gases. installing or removing consumable component parts with o-ring seals requires a force component to overcome the frictional drag force of the o-ring on the sealing surface.

These specially designed tools add cost to the system and complicate system usage. In addition, features must be added to the consumable component parts to interface with the tools adding to the overall cost of the parts.

Accordingly, a need exists to provide low-cost, readily-manufacturable, and easily-replaceable consumable components in a plasma arc torch, where the alignment and concentricity of the consumable components in the plasma arc torch can be closely controlled.

A component for a plasma arc torch includes a body portion, a tapered surface on the body portion, the tapered surface including a compressible member that provides a disengagement force relative to the body portion, and an axially disposed surface on the body portion for coupling to a mating surface on an adjacent structure of the torch. The component can be a nozzle and/or an electrode. The plasma arc torch can be liquid or gas cooled.

The compressible member can radially align the body portion with a central axis of the torch. The compressible member can provide a seal between the body portion and the torch. The compressible member can be an O-ring.

In one embodiment, the tapered surface on the body portion can have a clearance in the range of 0.00001 inches (0.000254 mm) to a value above zero with respect to a respective tapered surface of the torch. In another embodiment, the tapered surface may be touching at a point about the circumference of the body portion. The tapered surface can include a feature for receiving the compressible member, wherein the feature can be a recess defined by the body portion.

The axially disposed surface can be electrically coupled to the mating surface. The axially disposed surface can axially align the body portion in an axial position relative to the adjacent structure of the torch.

In another embodiment, a tool-free plasma torch includes a torch body, an electrode coupled to the torch body, a nozzle coupled to the torch body, the nozzle having a tapered surface including a compressible member that provides a disengagement force relative to an adjacent tapered surface of the torch body, and an axially disposed surface for coupling a mating surface on an adjacent structure of the torch body, and a retention cap coupled to the torch body to provide an engagement force for coupling the nozzle to the torch body. The electrode can further include a tapered surface including the compressible member for providing a disengagement force relative to an adjacent tapered surface of the torch body and an axially disposed surface for coupling a mating surface on an adjacent structure of the torch body.

The tool-free plasma torch can further include a spring element disposed between the electrode and the nozzle for providing a coupling force between the electrode and the torch body. The tool-free plasma torch can further include a swirl ring that includes a compressible member for providing a disengagement force relative to a tapered surface of the torch body. The spring element can be integrated with a swirl ring.

The compressible members can align at least one of the electrode, the nozzle, and the swirl ring with a central axis of the torch. The electrode and the swirl ring can be fixedly coupled to the torch body. The electrode and the nozzle can be electrically coupled to a cathode and an anode of the torch body, respectively. The shield can be hand tightened to the torch body.

In another embodiment, a plasma torch component can include a body portion, a tapered surface on the body portion dimensioned to receive a compressible member that provides a disengagement force relative to the body portion, an axially disposed surface on the body portion for aligning the body in an axial position relative to an adjacent structure of the torch and a mating surface for electrically coupling the component on the adjacent structure of the torch.

In another embodiment, a plasma torch component can include a body portion having an axial length and a radial width, an axial stop for aligning the body portion in the direction of the axial length, and a tapered surface on the body portion dimensioned to engage a compressible member, wherein when the component is assembled the compressible member creates a force having an axial direction and a radial direction, wherein the radial direction of the force aligns the component radially and the axial direction of the force biases the component in an unassembled direction.

In another embodiment, a plasma torch component can include a first component, an axial stop for rigidly aligning the first component in an axial direction relative to a second component, and a radial stop for flexibly aligning the first component in a radial direction relative to the second component and for biasing the first component in the axial direction. The first component can be a plasma torch body.

A method for aligning a first component in a plasma torch assembly, the first component having an axial stop and a tapered surface for engaging a compressible member, the method can include slidably engaging the axial stop of the first component to a second component of the plasma torch assembly to position the second component in an axial direction and biasing the compressible member against the tapered surface of the first component to radially align the first component to the second component.

In another embodiment, an assembly of plasma torch components can include a first component having an axial disposed surfaces and a tapered surface, a second component having an axial disposed surfaces, wherein the first component and the second component are aligned axially by their respective axial disposed surfaces, and a compression member aligning the first component and the second component radially, the compression member engaging the tapered surface such that the first component and the second component are biased in a direction of disassembly.

Advantages of the apparatus include high precision consumable component parts that are easily changeable without tools leading to reduce the overall system cost and ease of system usage.

The foregoing and other objects, features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the following more particular description of preferred embodiments of the invention, as illustrated in the accompanying drawings in which like reference characters refer to the same parts throughout the different views. The drawings are not necessarily to scale, emphasis instead being placed upon illustrating the principles of the invention.

FIG. 1 illustrates a plasma arc torch system;

FIG. 2 illustrates in simplified schematic form a plasma arc torch;

FIG. 3A is a simplified schematic diagram of a tool-free plasma arc torch;

FIG. 3B is an exploded view of the schematic diagram of FIG. 3A;

In FIG. 3C, a slidable nozzle 370a is maintained in an assembled position through the use of the retention cap 392 that holds the nozzle to an anode block 308a of the torch body 300. The anode block 308a includes a tapered alignment surface 314a. The nozzle includes a feature (e.g. a recess) 374a dimensioned to receive a compressible member 376. In this embodiment, the compressible member 376 sits within the recess 374a formed on the tapered surface 372a. When assembled, the compressible member 376 is compressed between the tapered surface 314a of the anode block 308a and the tapered surface 372a of the nozzle 370.

FIG. 4 shows an embodiment of a lower body portion, or “working end” 400 of a liquid or gas cooled-type plasma arc torch as shown in FIGS. 1 and 2. The working end 400 has a centrally disposed longitudinal axis 302 and includes a cathode block 304, a torch insulator 306, and an anode block 308, each block having respective tapered alignment surfaces 310, 312, 314. The cathode block 304 and the anode block 308 include respective axial stops 316, 318. In some embodiments, the tapered alignment surface 308, 314 of the cathode block 304 and the anode block 308 can include respective lead-ins 322, 326 for protecting consumable components from damage during installation. Further, the lead-ins 322, 326 are beneficial for component ejection by increasing axial force and reducing drag force on the components. The working end 400 further includes radially centered consumable components (an electrode 330, a swirl ring 350, a nozzle 370, and a shield 390). In some embodiments, each tapered alignment surface 308, 312, 314 can further include a compressible member (not shown) for providing a seal, a radial alignment force, and an axial disengagement force between the torch and the consumable components. In some embodiments, the torch is liquid or gas cooled.

The electrode 330 includes a tapered surface 332 for aligning with the first tapered alignment surface 310 of the working end 400 of the plasma arc torch. The tapered surface 322 includes a feature (e.g. a recess) 334 or is dimensioned to receive a compressible member 336. The compressible member 336, such as an O-ring, provides the following functions: 1) a seal between the electrode 330 and the plasma chamber to contain and separate process gases and torch coolant; 2) a radial stop creating a radial alignment force for flexibly aligning the electrode 330 in the radial direction; and 3) an axial disengagement force between the working end 400 and the electrode 330 for biasing the electrode 330 in an unassembled direction. In some embodiments, the tapered surface 332 has an axial extent of less than about 0.5 inches (1.27 cm) and, in some embodiments, less than about 0.25 inches (0.635 cm). The electrode 330 further includes an axial stop 338 for aligning the electrode 330 with the axial stop 316 of the cathode block 304. In some embodiments, the axial stops 316, 338 are rigidly coupled. Further, axial-to-axial stop 316, 338 allows for conduction of electrical current and thermal energy needed to operate the torch. It should be understood that electrically coupling of the electrode 330 to the cathode block 304 can be accomplished in other manner known in the art.

During installation, as the electrode 330 is installed in the working end 400 of the plasma arc torch, the tapered surface 332 is guided by the first tapered alignment surface 310 until the compressible member 336 comes to rest against first tapered alignment surface 310. The lead-in 322 on the first tapered alignment surface 310 prevents the compressible member or O-ring 336 from being damaged. As shown, in one embodiment a nominal clearance of 0.002 inches is provided between the taper surface 332 and the first tapered alignment surface 310 to prevent binding during installation.

In some embodiments, a swirl ring 350 can be disposed between the electrode 330 and the nozzle 370. The swirl ring 350 controls the fluid flow patterns on the plasma chamber front between the electrode 330 and the nozzle 370. The swirl ring 350 includes at least one feature (e.g. a recess) 354 or is dimensioned to receive a respective compressible member 356 for aligning with the second tapered alignment surface 312 of the working end 400 of the plasma arc torch. The compressible member 356, such as an O-ring, provides the following functions: 1) a seal between the swirl ring 350 and the plasma chamber to contain and separate process gases and torch coolant; 2) a radial stop creating a radial alignment force for flexibly aligning the swirl ring 350 in the radial direction; and 3) an axial disengagement force between the working end 400 and the swirl ring 350 for biasing the swirl ring 350 in an unassembled direction. In some embodiments, a spring element 358 is disposed between the electrode 330 and the swirl ring 350 to provide an engagement force of the electrode 330 and the cathode block 304 during installation. It should be understood that the spring element 358 can be disposed between the swirl ring 350 and the nozzle 370, integrated with the swirl ring 350, or provided in any configuration that provides engagement force of the electrode 330 to the cathode block 304.

During installation, as the swirl ring 350 is installed in the working end 400 of the plasma arc torch, the compressible member 356 comes to rest against second tapered alignment surface 312. It should be understood a non-integrated spring element 358 can be installed before or after the installation of the swirl ring 350 or in replacement of the swirl ring 350.

The nozzle 370 includes a tapered surface 372 for aligning with the third tapered alignment surface 314 of the working end 400 of the plasma arc torch. The tapered surface 372 includes a feature (e.g. a recess) 374 or is dimensioned to receive a compressible member 376. The compressible member 376, such as an O-ring, provides the following functions: 1) a seal between the nozzle 370 and the plasma chamber to contain and separate process gases and torch coolant; 2) a radial stop creating a radial alignment force for flexibly aligning the nozzle 370 in the radial direction; and 3) an axial disengagement force between the working end 400 and the nozzle 370 for biasing the nozzle 370 in an unassembled direction. In some embodiments, the tapered surface 372 has an axial extent of less than about 0.5 inches (1.27 cm). The nozzle 370 further includes an axial stop 378 for aligning the nozzle 370 with the axial stop 318 of the anode block 308. In some embodiments, the axial stops 318, 378 are rigidly coupled. Further, axial-to-axial stop 318, 378 allows for conduction of electrical current and thermal energy needed to operate the torch. It should be understood that electrically coupling of the nozzle 370 to the anode block 308 can be accomplished in other manner known in the art.

During installation, as the nozzle 370 is installed in the working end 400 of the plasma arc torch, the tapered surface 372 is guided by the third tapered alignment surface 314 until the compressible member 376 comes to rest against third tapered alignment surface 314. The lead-in 326 on the third tapered alignment surface 314 prevents the compressible member or O-ring 376 from being damaged. As shown, in one embodiment a nominal clearance of 0.002 inches is provided between the taper surface 372 and the third tapered alignment surface 314 to prevent binding during installation.

A hand-threaded retaining cap 392 may be employed to couple the consumables components to the torch body. The retaining cap 392 causes a force to be placed on the nozzle 370, the swirl ring 350, and the electrode 330 (through the spring element 358) that causes the longitudinal axis of these components to align with the torch axis 302. The force further seats these components with their respective counterparts of the working end 400 of the torch (e.g. the cathode block 304, the torch insulator 306, and the anode block 308).

The shield 390 is typically the outermost component of the working end 400 of the torch. In some embodiments, the shield 390 may be threadedly attached to the torch working end 400 or attached in a press-on configuration. In other embodiments, shield 390 may be connected to the torch body by retain cap 392. In such embodiments, the shield 390 may likewise include a tapered surface 372 for aligning with adjacent components. The tapered surface 372 may also include a feature (e.g. a recess) 374 to receive a compressible member 356. In some embodiments, the shield 390 may serve to function as the retaining cap thereby providing the necessary force to seat the consumable components.

During torch operation, the electrode 330, the swirl ring 350, the nozzle 370, and the shield 390 are subjected to harsh conditions, including high temperatures and other physical stresses. Consequently, these components degrade over time and eventually must be replaced, typically in the field. Prior techniques required the use of specialized tools to remove these components. In the above embodiment, the retaining cap 392 need only be removed by hand thereby allowing the axial component of the compression force on compressible members to assist in ejecting these components from the torch.

FIG. 4 demonstrates an embodiment incorporating both tool-free and conventional torch components. That is, some components may be conventional type threaded consumables and some components may be slidable as described above. This allows for a reduction cost for the components that are more likely to be replaced than others. That is, the consumable components closest to the plasma arc are more likely to wear and need replacement before the components further from the plasma arc. For example, the electrode 330 and the nozzle 370 are more likely to wear before the shield 390, and the shield 390 is more likely to wear before the swirl ring 350, etc.

In the embodiment of FIG. 5, the electrode 330 is threadedly attached to the cathode block 304 eliminating the need for the spring element 358 (FIG. 3) FIG. 4. The swirl ring 350, the nozzle 370, and the shield 390 are each coupled to the “working end” 400 of the plasma arc torch as mentioned above.

The electrode 330 of FIG. 5 includes a threaded surface 339 and a deformable surface, such as a lip. The threaded surface 339 engages a cooperating thread 319 of the cathode block 304. By threadedly attaching the electrode 330 to the cathode block 304, the electrode 304 is axially aligned with the torch axis 302 and properly spaced from the nozzle 350 during torch operation. The engagement of the threaded surface 339 with the cooperating thread 319 also serves as an electrical connection to conduct the requisite current between the cathode block 304 and the electrode 330.

In some embodiments, the swirl ring 350 may also include a threaded surface that engages a cooperating threaded surface on the torch insulator 306. In general, however, the swirl ring 350 is simply captured in the working end 400 of the torch by the retention cap. In either configuration, it is desirable to center the swirl ring 350 about the electrode 330 so as to provide a concentric uniform annular plasma chamber to provide uniform gas flow therein and facilitate torch operation.

FIGS. 3 and 4 show each tapered surface as a linear taper surface, however it should be understood that each tapered surface can be any number of shapes, including contoured surfaces and arcs. In general, the shape of the “tapered” surface can be understood to be any shape such that when two torch components are assembled, the tangent to the surface at the point of contact with compressible member is angled in the unassembled direction relative to the torch axis.

From the foregoing, it will be appreciated that the working end provides a simple and effective way to ensure the proper alignment of consumable components in the working end of a plasma arc torch. The problems of securing the critical alignments while operating under harsh field conditions, compounded by the need to replace components as they deteriorate from use, are largely eliminated. This avoids the unacceptable production errors affecting workpieces caused by improperly aligned apparatus and facilitates quick and easy replacement of the consumable components.

While this invention has been particularly shown and described with references to preferred embodiments thereof, it will be understood by those skilled in the art that various changes in form and details may be made therein without departing from the scope of the invention encompassed by the appended claims.

Liebold, Stephen M., Duan, Zheng, Lindsay, Jon W., Brandt, Aaron D., Bartlett, Brent R.

Patent Priority Assignee Title
Patent Priority Assignee Title
5317126, Jan 14 1992 BANK OF AMERICA, N A Nozzle and method of operation for a plasma arc torch
5841095, Oct 28 1996 BANK OF AMERICA, N A Apparatus and method for improved assembly concentricity in a plasma arc torch
6156995, Dec 02 1998 ESAB GROUP, INC , THE Water-injection nozzle assembly with insulated front end
6320156, May 10 1999 Komatsu Ltd. Plasma processing device, plasma torch and method for replacing components of same
6424082, Aug 03 2000 BANK OF AMERICA, N A Apparatus and method of improved consumable alignment in material processing apparatus
6614001, Aug 03 2000 BANK OF AMERICA, N A Nozzle for plasma arc torch
6979796, Feb 27 2003 Lincoln Global, Inc Method and apparatus for proper alignment of components in a plasma arc torch
20040200810,
20050108736,
20080173622,
CN2845398,
EP1006760,
GB2091594,
JP2004314181,
JP2005329434,
WO213583,
//////
Executed onAssignorAssigneeConveyanceFrameReelDoc
Mar 09 2007LINDSAY, JON W HYPERTHERM, INC ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS 0553770107 pdf
Mar 09 2007BARTLETT, BRENT R HYPERTHERM, INC ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS 0553770107 pdf
Mar 09 2007BRANDT, AARON D HYPERTHERM, INC ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS 0553770107 pdf
Mar 09 2007DUAN, ZHENGHYPERTHERM, INC ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS 0553770107 pdf
Mar 12 2007LIEBOLD, STEPHEN M HYPERTHERM, INC ASSIGNMENT OF ASSIGNORS INTEREST SEE DOCUMENT FOR DETAILS 0553770107 pdf
Oct 02 2020Hypertherm, Inc.(assignment on the face of the patent)
Date Maintenance Fee Events
Oct 02 2020BIG: Entity status set to Undiscounted (note the period is included in the code).


Date Maintenance Schedule
Jul 26 20254 years fee payment window open
Jan 26 20266 months grace period start (w surcharge)
Jul 26 2026patent expiry (for year 4)
Jul 26 20282 years to revive unintentionally abandoned end. (for year 4)
Jul 26 20298 years fee payment window open
Jan 26 20306 months grace period start (w surcharge)
Jul 26 2030patent expiry (for year 8)
Jul 26 20322 years to revive unintentionally abandoned end. (for year 8)
Jul 26 203312 years fee payment window open
Jan 26 20346 months grace period start (w surcharge)
Jul 26 2034patent expiry (for year 12)
Jul 26 20362 years to revive unintentionally abandoned end. (for year 12)